This is the transcript of Restitutio episode 679: The Devil Debate with Will Barlow and Jon Burke This transcript was auto-generated and only approximates the contents of this episode. Audio file 679 Devil Debate.mp3 Transcript 00:03 Sean Finnegan Welcome to Restitudio, podcast seeking to recover authentic Christianity and live it out. Today, I'm your host, Sean Finnegan, and I'm really excited today to host a debate on the resolution, the devil and demons exist as supernatural evil beings, in which Will Barlow affirms and Jonathan Burke denies 00:28 Sean Finnegan I think this should be a very interesting and hopefully a little bit lively conversation between these two gentlemen, these two fellow Christians. And even before we go much further, would you do me a favor and subscribe to this channel so you don't miss out more content? We're going to be releasing content pretty much every week on YouTube. So if you like what you see here, why not subscribe? 00:51 Sean Finnegan And if you want to learn more about me, more about Restitudio, you can find out, or if you'd like to support us, you can do that at our website, restitudio.org. There's all the information there about the podcast. Now, as I said before, we have two debaters today. And I'd like to tell you first about Jonathan Burke. He was raised in the Christadelphian community, baptized at 19, and has been a member ever 01:17 Sean Finnegan sense his particular areas of Bible study have included hermeneutics prophecy creation atonement biblical mortalism I think he's written a book on that and the general topic of evil including Satan and demons uh when I was going to put this debate together I can't even tell you how many people said you've got to get John Jonathan Burke is the guy uh so I'm very thrilled to say 01:43 Sean Finnegan that he has agreed and that he is here. He has written a number of books defending the reliability of the Bible and its message generally as well as defending certain Christadelphian views specifically. He has been published in two peer-reviewed scholarly journals, presenting several academic conference papers and written a large number of individual articles for Christadelphian journals. 02:06 Sean Finnegan John spent 20 years living in Taiwan, unbelievable, as a missionary, during which time he helped found a Christelphian congregation and was responsible for the instruction and baptism of several people into Christ. Now, I have known John for I think about 20 years. 02:26 Jon Burke Oh yeah, long time now, yeah. 02:29 Sean Finnegan It's been a long time and we came across each other 02:33 Sean Finnegan I ran a blog called Kingdom Ready. And I got to meet John and his twin brother Dave in New Zealand in 2024. So welcome, John, Jonathan Burke, Jono, the man, the legend, the myth. Here he is. And fun fact about John is he's a swordsman. So he can he knows his way around his sword. Thankfully, that's not 02:58 Will Barlow Yeah, he's far enough away. I don't have to worry about that. That's good. 03:03 Sean Finnegan But yeah, he really has a lot of experience fencing. And so welcome, John. So glad to have you today. 03:10 Jon Burke Thank you, Sean. Really appreciate it. 03:12 Sean Finnegan Okay, so for our other contestant, I don't know if that's the right word, our other debater, 03:18 Sean Finnegan is Pastor Will Barlow. He grew up in a family that loved God at age 16. He felt the call to ministry. He received a bachelor's degree in physics and mathematics from Vanderbilt University in 2008 and a master's degree in secondary education from Ohio State. I guess I have to say the Ohio State in 2010. He's the author of God and Science, Is Faith in God Rational? 03:45 Sean Finnegan explore what we believe, and several UCA presentations and book chapters, including his latest, which is on the question of whether or not you have to believe Jesus is God in order to be saved, that God died for your sins in order to provide salvation, which is forthcoming on the UCA YouTube channel. 04:06 Sean Finnegan Will lives just outside of Louisville, Kentucky with his wife of 17 years, Rebecca, and his three children, Liam, Hannah, and Isaac. He serves as the head pastor of Compass Christian Church, which is a biblical Unitarian church located in Louisville, Kentucky. So welcome to the show, Will Barlow. Thanks for joining us. 04:27 Will Barlow Thank you. Happy to be here. 04:30 Sean Finnegan Very good. So our schedule today is 04:34 Sean Finnegan as follows. Let me go ahead and pull that up. We have a opening statement of 15 minutes for each person, followed by rebuttals of 15 minutes each, cross examinations of 15 minutes each, closings of 5 minutes each, and then audience Q&A for 20 minutes. And I just kept the order the same the whole time. I hope that's 04:57 Sean Finnegan with you guys? Just go Will John, Will John, Will John. And there are advantages, of course, to going 1st and there are advantages to going second. And that's all been worked out ahead of time. So I think we'll just stick with that schedule. All right. So first up, we're going to begin with Will Barlow and his opening statement. He's affirming the proposition that the devil and demons exist as literal supernatural evil beings. 05:24 Sean Finnegan What I'm going to do, Will, is go ahead and give you a one minute warning when we've got a minute left. And we go ahead and pull up your slides here. And your time will start now. 05:43 Will Barlow Thank you. Well, good afternoon or morning. 05:46 Will Barlow I'm thankful to my friend Sean Finnegan for hosting this debate and to my dialogue partner Jonathan Burke for graciously agreeing to discuss this important topic. At the beginning of a debate, I often like to contextualize the conversation to help focus the audience on key details. Here are some important things for me to clarify here at the beginning. Individual humans are responsible for sin. There is no, the devil made me do it. 06:12 Will Barlow Certain biblical passages are visionary, parabolic, or figurative in some way. The greater question is the worldview behind such figures. For the purpose of this debate, I'm agnostic on the origin of the devil and demons, although I lean heavily toward the fallen angel view. I believe the words Satan and devil can refer to human beings at times, and I also believe that scripture frequently personifies abstract concepts like wisdom. 06:39 Will Barlow The question we're debating isn't whether human beings are responsible for sin, whether scripture uses figurative language, or whether the word Satan can refer to human adversaries. We all agree on those things. The question is whether scripture also teaches that personal supernatural agents of evil exist. And I believe the answer is unmistakably yes. Put another way, the Bible describes Jesus as teaching about the kingdom of Satan and as interacting with demons. 07:06 Will Barlow Paul and the other apostles speak of this grand conflict between good and evil that includes supernatural agents of both good and evil. And so, yes, I believe that the devil and demons exist as literal personal supernatural agents of evil. Further, my goal in this presentation is to give a coherent worldview that explains the evidence from all sources and provides the most holistic and complete explanation of all the evidence. 07:32 Will Barlow First, let's talk about the Hebrew scriptures or the Old Testament. I will concede that the Old Testament does not give a coherent and clear theology of the devil and demons. In fact, John has conceded in past debates that his view also is not clearly taught in the Old Testament. So the truth is that both of us are doing our best to reconstruct a doctrine using mostly the New Testament, historical arguments, and psychology. 07:57 Will Barlow Nonetheless, I think that there are clear clues in the Old Testament that the people of Israel believed in multiple supernatural entities, including evil ones. For example, the book of Job describes a conversation between the Satan and God in his heavenly court. And while I'm sympathetic to the idea that the whole book of Job is possibly an extended parable, the truth remains that the parable is based on factual realities. 08:21 Will Barlow For example, the fact that God convenes the heavenly court where angels come and go is uncontroversial. Therefore, deniers of a literal Satan have to provide an argument more than this is a parable. And in particular, while the actions attributed to the Satan partially hinge on human activity, there is supernatural fire and wind involved as well as physical ailments. 08:43 Will Barlow In particular, Christadelphian Duncan Heaster admits in his book that perhaps the best explanation of these supernatural activities is that God sent an angel to afflict Job. Of course, we could talk about the serpent in the garden in Genesis 3, which becomes a biblical metaphor for evil in the world throughout scripture. And while John may be able to salvage a non-literal devil by explaining that Adam and Eve were just grasping, 09:08 Will Barlow at being gods themselves, the problem emerges more as the Bible continues referring to this metaphor over and over again. Notably, we find Paul referring to this in 2 Corinthians 11 when he says, But I am afraid that as a serpent deceived Eve by his cunning, your thoughts will be led astray from a sincere and pure devotion to Christ. Now, while John may pounce on this verse and say, see, this is relating to the serpent's deception in our own thoughts, 09:35 Will Barlow I would caution a consideration of the verb tense here, which is passive. The passive voice usually displays that the subject does not do the action. This runs entirely counter to the Christadelphian claim that the serpent is our internal thoughts and motivations. Now further references to the serpent include Revelation 12.9 and chapter 20 verse 2. And while some commentators interpret these as references to Rome, many also find a supernatural devil or Satan there as well. 10:03 Will Barlow But perhaps the greatest window into supernatural evil comes in the book of Daniel. And this text provides a gateway into later New Testament treatment of the same concept, this ongoing war between the powers of good and evil. In this context, Daniel has been praying for weeks about a vision he received. After 3 weeks, an angel shows up and starts talking to Daniel. We'll pick it up in verse 13. 10:27 Will Barlow The prince of the kingdom of Persia withstood me 21 days. This is the angel speaking. But Michael, one of the chief princes, came to help me, for I was left there with the kings of Persia, and came to make you understand what is to happen to your people in the latter days, for the vision is for days yet to come. What we can see clearly here is that the prince of Persia is strong enough to fend off an angel of God who is a supernatural being. 10:53 Will Barlow We also have the same word prince being used of the evil supernatural being, the Prince of Persia, alongside the Archangel Michael. This is strong evidence that the ancient Hebrews believed in the existence of supernatural evil beings. Now let's talk about the New Testament. In particular, here are some New Testament facts inconsistent with the Christadelphian understanding. 11:16 Will Barlow We will go through these now one by one. The first one is, every New Testament writer seems to believe in a devil and or demons as literal, personal, supernatural agents of evil. Now here's a partial list of verses consistent with this belief, each with its own exgetical concerns that support my view. And I'm not intending to shotgun or machine gun these verses. I just want to give one example which John can interact with, and that is 2 Corinthians 11. 11:46 Will Barlow And no wonder for even Satan, or the Satan in Greek, disguises himself as an angel of light. So it is no surprise if his servants also disguise themselves as servants of righteousness. Their end will correspond to their deeds. Not only do we have the Satan with the article, but also an intensive masculine pronoun with a middle verb that results in a reflexive meaning, Satan himself. 12:13 Will Barlow In this context, we see the Satan as a personal agent capable of sending other personal agents. The second thing I want to say is that there are accounts in the gospels inconsistent with the Christadelphian accommodation argument because they grant the possessed ones powers unexplainable by fallen human natures or mental illness. For example, in Matthew 8, Mark 5, and Luke 8, Jesus meets a demon-possessed man with supernatural strength. 12:40 Will Barlow The Bible says that he was able to break bonds and that no one was able to subdue him. This isolated man also instantly recognizes Jesus as the Son of the Most High God. Supernatural strength and knowledge are incompatible with the Christadelphian view. In Acts 16, we read of a young woman with the spirit of divination who was a fortune teller. After the spirit was removed by Paul, the young woman no longer told fortunes. 13:05 Will Barlow In Mark 1, we read of a man with an unclean spirit who knew Jesus' name, his birthplace, and his identity as the Holy One of God. He also verbalizes interesting information about the judgment for demons. Third, Jesus distinguishes Satan from the human beings Satan influences. The Gospel of John largely portrays Jesus' ministry as a struggle between the powers of good and evil, with the religious leaders largely opposing Jesus. 13:32 Will Barlow To this point, when Jesus confronts these leaders, he tells them that they are of their father, the devil. We read in John 8.44, You are of your father, the devil, and your will is to do your father's desires. He was a murderer from the beginning and does not stand in the truth because there is no truth in him. When he lies, he speaks out of his own character, for he is a liar and the father of lies. 13:56 Will Barlow The devil grammatically has the article and has attributed aspects of personhood, including desires, the ability to commit murder and lie, and a character separate from the human persons Jesus is addressing. Fourth, Jesus also distinguishes between demons and the people they possess. In the account in Mark 5 of the man possessed by legion, many demons, 14:18 Will Barlow This is what happens. We pick it up in verse 6. And when he saw Jesus from afar, he ran and fell down before him. And crying out with a loud voice, he said, What have you do with me, Jesus, Son of the Most High God? I adjure you by God, do not torment me. For he was saying to him, Come out of the man, you unclean spirit. And Jesus asked him, What is your name? He replied, My name is Legion, for we are many. And he begged him earnestly not to send them out of the country. 14:47 Will Barlow Now a great herd of pigs was feeding there on the hillside, and they begged him, saying, send us to the pigs, let us enter them. So he gave them permission. And the unclean spirits came out and entered the pigs, and the herd, numbering about 2,000, rushed down the steep bank into the sea and drowned in the sea. Some important things to point out. The man and the demons are described as distinct agents, with the plural they referring to the demons. We see this in Luke's account as well. 15:15 Will Barlow The demons recognize Jesus and speak to him. Matthew 8.31 is explicit on this point as well. The man is in Gentile country with limited access to the story of the people of God and the prophecies of the Messiah, and yet this man uses a Messianic title for Jesus. They, the demons, beg Jesus not to torment them. They request permission to enter a herd of pigs. Jesus grants their request. 15:39 Will Barlow The demons leave the man and enter the pigs who plunge to their deaths, and the man is subsequently described as restored to his right mind. These are important details to consider. And finally, the New Testament portrays our daily lives as a struggle of good versus evil, using language of personal agents on both sides of the conflict. And perhaps the greatest example of this comes from Paul's epistle to the Ephesians. 16:02 Will Barlow In Ephesians 6 we read, Put on the whole armor of God, that you may be able to stand against the schemes of the devil. For we do not wrestle against flesh and blood, but against the rulers, against the authorities, against the cosmic powers over this present darkness, against the spiritual forces of evil in the heavenly places. The word devil here has the article. Paul talks about schemes, methods of acting in the world, and he specifically says that it isn't related to flesh and blood and then uses power language. 16:31 Will Barlow I don't know how much more explicit that Paul could be. Spiritual forces of evil in the heavenly places. Now to end my biblical case, I want to address the question, why do the ancient Hebrews not have a clear conception of supernatural evil beings while the New Testament does? My dialogue partner maybe will blame the Persian Empire's influence on Hebrew thought after the close of most of the Old Testament canon. 16:54 Will Barlow This is why, for example, the Book of Enoch is replete with stories of demons and evil supernatural beings, but the canonical literature is not. The Bible, however, gives a different answer to this question. In 1 John chapter 3, verse 8, we read, Whoever makes a practice of sinning is of the devil, for the devil has been sinning from the beginning. The reason the Son of God appeared was to destroy the works of the devil. 17:18 Will Barlow In 1st John, we see that a primary reason for Jesus coming is to, quote, destroy the works of the devil, unquote, that is to undo what the devil has done by telling lies, capturing people in darkness, and so on. The grammar of this verse assumes that the devil is a literal supernatural being capable of, quote, sinning from the beginning, perhaps from the beginning of the story of the people of God in Genesis 3. 17:43 Will Barlow Part of Jesus' unique role was to expose and then destroy the works of the devil, which is why we see Jesus expelling demons and overcoming temptation throughout the gospel narratives. My next argument has to deal with early church history, and I want to point out that the early church also documents exorcisms and the literal existence of the devil and demons. Just to give 4 examples, Justin Martyr describes exorcism 18:06 Will Barlow and that the world is under the influence of wicked angels and demons, but that nonetheless, men by free choice either act rightly or commit sin. That's in Second Apology, chapter 6 and 7. Ireneus in Against Heresies, Book 2, chapter 2, paragraph 4, believes in exorcisms. Tertullian in Apology, chapter 22 and 23 describes how demons can influence human affairs and deceive people, and he also describes his belief in exorcism. 18:33 Will Barlow And Origen also talks about exorcisms and against Celsus. And the list goes on and on. I would ask Mr. Burke for a church father that believes what he does about the devil and demons. My contention is that while there are nuanced and differing views on the devil and demons throughout church history, there is nothing significantly similar to John's view until well past the beginning of the Protestant Reformation. 18:56 Will Barlow And my further contention is that the development of the Christadelphian view is heavily influenced by post-enlightened sensibilities on the miraculous. He will likely point to post-biblical and medieval Jewish sources to make his case without recognizing that some of those writers believed in the evil inclination or yetzer hurrah and a literal Satan. The ancient Jews did not think that these ideas are mutually exclusive and neither do I. 19:23 Will Barlow Finally, I want to talk about how my worldview can better explain phenomena in human psychology and the massive evil that we are increasingly aware of in modern times. My belief is that the Christadelphian view can handle the mundane types of sin, the lust, the violence, and the anger. In my opinion, the Christadelphian view struggles to explain the more extreme types of sin and evil found, for example, in leaders like Hitler, Stalin, and 19:53 Will Barlow or in things like sex trafficking and child exploitation. The Christadelphian view is that these people are mentally unwell. My view is that this isn't descriptive enough and doesn't explain enough. The biblical framework given by Jesus and the apostles is that the forces of evil fight against the forces of good. The big question we should ask over and over again is this. 20:18 Will Barlow Why do Jesus and the apostles consistently speak of the devil and demons as actual agents in the spiritual conflict all around us? 20:29 Will Barlow My answer is to take Jesus and the apostles at their word. 20:34 Will Barlow The question before us is not whether we can reinterpret individual passages to accommodate A worldview in which the devil and demons do not exist. 20:44 Will Barlow The question is whether that worldview adequately explains the totality of Scripture. 20:49 Will Barlow When Jesus describes Satan's kingdom, when demons speak to him and negotiate with him, when Paul describes spiritual forces of evil, and when the earliest Christians consistently understood these beings to be real, we must ask which interpretation best explains the evidence. 21:06 Will Barlow I believe the answer is clear. 21:09 Will Barlow Thank you. 21:10 Sean Finnegan All right. 21:11 Sean Finnegan Thank you, Will Barlow, for that opening statement. 21:17 Sean Finnegan We are now going to go to John Burke, who's going to deny the proposition that the devil and demons exist as literal supernatural evil beings. 21:29 Sean Finnegan Let's go ahead and pull that up. 21:34 Sean Finnegan Okay. 21:36 Sean Finnegan All right, John, you have 15 minutes. 21:39 Sean Finnegan Your time begins. 21:41 Jon Burke Thank you, Sean, and thank you, Will. 21:43 Jon Burke I'm really glad that Will has actually cleared a lot of ground. 21:46 Jon Burke We have a lot on which we do agree. 21:49 Jon Burke And I like in particular the points that he's raised. 21:52 Jon Burke And you'll notice that in fact, my presentation anticipated some of those points. 21:57 Jon Burke I'm going to speak to the argument that Satan and demons are not supernatural evil beings. 22:02 Jon Burke And I'm going to start with my argument from hermeneutical consistency. 22:09 Jon Burke We Unitarians are monists. 22:10 Jon Burke We believe there is only one God, that God is one person, that humans are mortal, that all power derives from God, that God is the only source of immortality, and that angels and humans are dependent on God. 22:23 Jon Burke Consequently, if we say Satan has supernatural power or immortality, then God must have given it to him, in which case, why would he do that? 22:33 Jon Burke If we say Satan possesses power or immortality independently of God, without God giving them to him, then we make him a source of power or immortality other than God. 22:42 Jon Burke And to me, that is hermeneutically inconsistent with Unitarianism. 22:47 Jon Burke As Will has already pointed out, as Unitarians, we do interpret texts contextually. 22:52 Jon Burke We don't simply read the English words on the page and anticipate that that is their literal meaning. 22:57 Jon Burke We read passages such as in hell as he was in torment and the smoke from their torment, and we understand they are not referring to immortal beings or immortal souls being burned in hell. 23:07 Jon Burke Likewise, we read 23:09 Jon Burke passages such as the Father and I are one and my Lord and my God, and we recognize that they do not refer to Jesus as God or a Trinity. 23:18 Jon Burke So as Will has already demonstrated and agreed, figurative readings are standard Unitarian practice, and the real debate occurs over how we identify which are figurative and which are to be taken in a more literal sense. 23:31 Jon Burke And as Will would understand, and I know he agrees, 23:34 Jon Burke We need to use sources such as lexicons and historical texts to understand what these terms mean. 23:39 Jon Burke And we've seen how Will uses those, and you'll see soon how I use them. 23:44 Jon Burke Very importantly, as Unitarians, we harmonize the testaments. 23:47 Jon Burke And you can see that Will is fully aware of this, and he has his own method of doing that. 23:52 Jon Burke As Unitarians, we believe the Old and New Testament both teach there is one God who is one person. 23:58 Jon Burke that there is a human Messiah who is the Son of God, that humans are mortal, and that God's kingdom will be on earth. 24:04 Jon Burke Now, as Will would acknowledge in the Old Testament, there is no clear evil angel Satan, or Satan as an evil supernatural being. 24:14 Jon Burke So my question is, why would there be one in the New Testament? 24:17 Jon Burke I know Will has given his answer to that, and I will address that shortly. 24:21 Jon Burke Likewise, as far as I can see, there are no evil demons or spirits in the Old Testament. 24:26 Jon Burke So I would question why they would be there in the New Testament. 24:29 Jon Burke And again, Will has given his answer to that and I will be addressing that consequently. 24:35 Jon Burke So what does the Old Testament actually say about Satan and demons? 24:40 Jon Burke It doesn't say much, but what it does say is revealing. 24:44 Jon Burke Mainstream scholarship agrees that the word Satan is predominantly used of an obedient angel in Numbers, possibly in Job and Zechariah, and of humans, definitely in Chronicles, Esther, Psalms, possibly in Job and Zechariah. 25:02 Jon Burke In fact, I believe both Job and Zechariah make a good case for a human agent here. 25:09 Jon Burke Mainstream scholarship agrees that the Satan of 1 Chronicles 21.1, for example, is understood to be an enemy nation, which provoked David to number the people for war. 25:18 Jon Burke And of course, as early as the Qumran Scrolls in the Dead Sea Scrolls, the Satan of Zechariah was already understood to be a personification of the human impulse to sin. 25:29 Jon Burke And some scholars believe that 25:31 Jon Burke it may have been an obedient angel. 25:35 Jon Burke What is a spirit? 25:37 Jon Burke In the Old Testament, we find an evil spirit identified as a spirit of animosity between a group of people in Judges 9:23. 25:45 Jon Burke And we find an evil spirit sent to Saul from God as a punishment in 1 Samuel 16:14. 25:51 Jon Burke We also find a lying spirit from God 25:54 Jon Burke sent to deceive his enemy, which is identified as an obedient angel in 1 Kings 22:19-23 and the corresponding record in 2 Chronicles. 26:03 Jon Burke And mainstream scholarship agrees these are not references to supernatural evil beings. 26:08 Jon Burke And we find that modern day Bibles and Bible translations and commentaries make this very clear. 26:15 Jon Burke Consequently, it is very clear that not only that there are no evil spirits and demons 26:20 Jon Burke in the Old Testament, but that in fact the role that they would otherwise have is carried out at best either by humans or obedient angelic messengers of God. 26:32 Jon Burke This, in my view, leaves no place for the Bible or the Jewish people believing, the Old Testament that is, believing in supernatural evil beings, but yet choosing not to reveal it until the time of Christ. 26:47 Jon Burke So what is a demon? 26:49 Jon Burke In the Old Testament, we find demons are defined explicitly as the foreign gods of the heathen. 26:55 Jon Burke Deuteronomy 32, verse 17, they sacrificed to demons, not God, to gods they had not known, to new gods who had recently come along. 27:03 Jon Burke So Deuteronomy 32, 17 tells us a demon is one of the false gods of the heathen, which do not exist. 27:08 Jon Burke And of course, mainstream scholarship agrees with this interpretation of Deuteronomy 32, 17. 27:14 Jon Burke In the Old Testament, as Will would recognise, Satan only appears at most three times. 27:20 Jon Burke Mainstream scholarship understands, as Will has acknowledged, that the Old Testament is remarkably silent on Satan. 27:28 Jon Burke Now, Will already know this, but for the benefit of anyone who is wondering, of course, just because scholars say something, it doesn't mean it's true. 27:37 Jon Burke And when Will and I 27:39 Jon Burke cite scholarship, we are not saying that something is true just because a lot of scholars say so. 27:44 Jon Burke But it is worth noting how mainstream scholarship has radically changed its views on Satan and demons in the Old Testament in particular, just as it has largely abandoned the idea that the Trinity or a mortal soul are taught anywhere in the Bible. 27:59 Jon Burke So scholars recognize the traditional understanding of Satan is nowhere in the Old Testament. 28:05 Jon Burke This is not even the case of them arguing that it is there but was hidden and unrevealed until the New Testament era. 28:11 Jon Burke They believe it wasn't there. 28:13 Jon Burke In the same way that Trinitarians say the belief in the Trinity was held or at least foreshadowed in the Old Testament and then later revealed in the New Testament, why would God wait for so long to reveal something so significant to his people? 28:27 Jon Burke In the case of the Old Testament, of course, a couple of thousand years. 28:31 Jon Burke Of course, there's a scholarly consensus that the Satan and demons of popular theology are not in the Old Testament. 28:36 Jon Burke Consequently, if somebody finds them in the New Testament, we must ask where they imported these ideas from. 28:44 Jon Burke I also argue that the Old and New Testament maintain a doctrinal continuity on these subjects. 28:50 Jon Burke And I will actually 28:52 Jon Burke Push back a little bit on Will's argument, I believe that the evil inclination is articulated clearly in the Old Testament as the cause of sin, and that this understanding of the origin of evil and sin is continued over into the New Testament. 29:09 Jon Burke 6, we find Eve saw that tree's fruit was good, she desired it, and she ate it. 29:13 Jon Burke Despite the fact that we are told she was spoken to by the serpent, Eve's own desire is identified as the cause of her sin. 29:22 Jon Burke 5, we find the first reference to what the later rabbis and other Jewish scholars referred to as the evil inclination or evil impulse, which causes humans to become tempted and sin. 29:34 Jon Burke Mainstream scholarship tells us this evil inclination became a significant theological term in Jewish literature after the Old Testament and well into the Christian era and was widely understood as the primary cause of temptation and sin. 29:47 Jon Burke And very significantly, in some Jewish literature, it was even personified even before the Christian era, despite remaining an internal source of sin. 29:57 Jon Burke Consequently, there is obviously a background in the Old Testament for an evil inclination as the primary source of sin, and also in pre-Christian Jewish literature for a personified evil inclination 30:11 Jon Burke as a source of sin for humans. 30:13 Jon Burke And we find that this same evil inclination is identified in the New Testament as the main battle, the main source of sin. 30:21 Jon Burke The New Testament clearly inherited this concept of the evil inclination as the primary source of temptation and sin. 30:27 Jon Burke Matthew 5.19 says all evil deeds originate in the heart. 30:30 Jon Burke In Acts 5.3, Peter tells Ananias that Satan has filled his heart, which Peter explained with the parallelism, you contrived this deed in your heart. 30:40 Jon Burke clearly identifying this Satan as Ananias' own evil inclination. 30:46 Jon Burke 23, Paul speaks of the evil inclination warring inside him, causing him to sin. 30:51 Jon Burke And James likewise tells us everyone is tempted when they are lured and enticed by their own desires, the evil inclination. 30:59 Jon Burke And mainstream scholarship recognizes the references in Paul and James in particular to be a continuation of the Jewish understanding of the evil inclination. 31:08 Jon Burke Kenus speaks of Paul's reference to the evil 31:09 Jon Burke impulse in Romans seven, and Mount similarly says that Paul's reference to sin living in him is a reference to the evil impulse. 31:16 Jon Burke Likewise, Martin and Zuck both identify James description of the process of evil and sin as referring specifically to the Old Testament concept of the evil inclination, which had been developed by Jewish literature. 31:28 Jon Burke This shows the concept of the evil inclination, which clearly originated in the Old Testament. 31:33 Jon Burke and which was cited as the cause of sin in Second Temple Period Judaism, and where it was also even personified, was carried over and used in the New Testament as the primary explanation for temptation and sin. 31:47 Jon Burke So there is a clear doctrinal continuity here from the Old Testament right through the Second Temple Period into the New Testament. 31:55 Jon Burke What does the New Testament say demons are? 31:58 Jon Burke just like Junior 1, Luke 32, we find outside the Gospels, demons are only identified as the foreign gods of the heathen, which is the Old Testament definition of demons in the passage of Deuteronomy we read previously. 32:10 Jon Burke In Acts, the word is used only once in Acts 17.18, where Paul's Greek audience understands the term demons to refer to foreign gods, just like the Old Testament. 32:21 Jon Burke Likewise, Paul only ever speaks of demons when he defines them as the gods of the heathen, which do not exist. 32:27 Jon Burke He never speaks of demons as personal beings, nor does he speak of demonic possession, nor even does he speak of exorcism. 32:35 Jon Burke 20 defines demons as the foreign gods and idols worshipped by the rebellious, not supernatural evil beings which possess people and require exorcism. 32:45 Jon Burke Revelation is particularly clear on the identification of demons as gods made by human hands, represented by lifeless evils, lifeless idols. 32:54 Jon Burke And this is recognized by mainstream scholarship. 32:56 Jon Burke Carpy says in Acts 1718, Paul's audience refers to understands him to be referring to foreign gods, and Kelly likewise says Paul considered demons to be just lifeless idols. 33:07 Jon Burke Now let's look at a late 1st century Christian text called the Didache, which is the earliest and longest systematic Christian doctrinal statement outside the New Testament. 33:16 Jon Burke You'll note Will began his commentary on the early church writings in the mid 2nd century. 33:23 Jon Burke I'd like to go back about 60 years, at least 60 years earlier than that, to the end of the 1st century. 33:30 Jon Burke This is the Didache. 33:32 Jon Burke It never refers to evil angels, demons, evil spirits, unclean spirits, demonic possession or exorcism. 33:38 Jon Burke No reference is made to them even when discussing topics in which they are typically used as an explanation by first century Jewish or even early second century Christian texts. 33:48 Jon Burke The Didache condemns idolatry without reference to demons, saying idle food is to be rejected since it is the worship of dead gods. 33:57 Jon Burke Mainstream scholarship recognizes the Didache used a Jewish source talking about the two ways of life, good and evil, which described how humans could be led astray by supernatural powers. 34:06 Jon Burke But when the Didache's authors used this source, they deliberately left out all the references to supernatural evil. 34:14 Jon Burke Milavec says later Christian sources clearly embrace an angelic dualism when defining the two ways, while the framers of the Didache clearly avoid it. 34:22 Jon Burke Jenks likewise says when the Didache 34:24 Jon Burke the same material as the Epistle of Barnabas, which referred explicitly to evil spirits and Satan as a supernatural evil power, the Didache deliberately left out any such references. 34:35 Jon Burke I believe this is extremely significant for our understanding of the New Testament. 34:39 Jon Burke Here are early Christians, well before the Reformation, well before the Enlightenment era, who believed as I believe on these matters. 34:46 Jon Burke Kloppenborg likewise says that Didache only describes an ethical and psychological dualism that is evil originating from within the human heart, not a dualism between supernatural good and evil powers. 34:58 Jon Burke And Millevec likewise says the writers of the Didache referred to idols as dead gods, refusing to give any support to the idea that they had any real power. 35:06 Jon Burke So in my view, there is clear evidence for late first century Christians holding to the Christodelvian view of temptation and sin and actually actively rejecting the alternative 35:16 Jon Burke of a supernatural evil cause. 35:18 Jon Burke Now let's see how belief in supernatural and demons is an extra-biblical doctrinal development. 35:24 Jon Burke In the Second Temple period, the Greek and Hebrew words for Satan are used of the inclination for sin as a common noun for humans or as a reference to an obedient angel. 35:36 Jon Burke Likewise, the word for diabolos, the diabolos, the word for devil, is used for humans and as a common noun. 35:44 Jon Burke Possibly as a reference to an obedient angel of God. 35:48 Sean Finnegan One minute left. 35:49 Jon Burke Second Temple period terms used inconsistently for a range of evil or obedient angelic figures include Azazel, Beelzebub, Beliah or Belial, Mestima, who's an obedient servant of God, Samael, who is the angel of death, another obedient angel of God, and Shamehazi. 36:05 Jon Burke But Satan is never used as the personal name of 36:08 Jon Burke an evil supernatural being. 36:10 Jon Burke Paul's single use of Belial matches its Old Testament use of that which is worthless or rebellious. 36:16 Jon Burke Very importantly, in the Second Temple period, we find there are pre-Christian and even Christian era Jewish sources showing that not all Jews believed in supernatural evil. 36:27 Jon Burke Not just that they believed in the evil inclination and supernatural evil, 36:31 Jon Burke but they rejected such beliefs of supernatural evil. 36:34 Jon Burke Bamberger notes that this is found in the book of Maccabees, the wisdom of Sirach, second Baruch, and for Ezra. 36:41 Jon Burke Likewise, Bamberger says that beliefs in supernatural evil were never accepted by all Jewish teachers, and that many pre-Christian Jewish commentators rejected them, and that would explain the background to the Didache which we have seen. 36:53 Jon Burke Consequently, Guy Williams and Andy Lato write, there was no standard Jewish Satan figure or belief or no Jewish tradition of a supernatural evil being called Satan before the Christian era. 37:04 Jon Burke It was not until the second century BCE, we are told, that due to outside pagan influences, the evil inclination was first conceived as an independent evil force with a sinister mind of its own. 37:16 Jon Burke This is clear doctrinal development. 37:19 Jon Burke Likewise, Carr tells us that the concept of mighty forces that are hostile from man to man, from which he sought relief, supernatural evil, was not prevalent in the thought world of the first century. 37:31 Jon Burke We do find, as Will noted in the second century, these beliefs start to become developed. 37:38 Jon Burke Thanks, Sean. 37:39 Jon Burke I'll just finish this last slide. 37:40 Jon Burke Justin Martyr is the first to identify the Eden serpent as Satan, and he identifies demons as the souls of dead men. 37:47 Jon Burke Theophilus 37:47 Jon Burke is the one who claims that Satan was religiously an angel, and then Tashen later claims demons are false fallen angels. 37:54 Jon Burke But I believe we do not find these either in the Old Testament or the New, and the fact that they appear first from the mid 2nd century onwards shows they are extra biblical developments just like the Trinity. 38:04 Jon Burke Thank you for your patience, John. 38:07 Sean Finnegan All right. 38:07 Sean Finnegan Well, thank you so much, John, for that rousing 15-minute opening. 38:12 Sean Finnegan We are 38:14 Sean Finnegan Right about here in our debate, we have finished our opening statements and we are now commencing our rebuttals. 38:22 Sean Finnegan So we have 15 minutes each with the first person up being Will. 38:28 Sean Finnegan So let me go ahead and add him. 38:30 Sean Finnegan And do you want your slides, Will? 38:32 Will Barlow That'd be great. 38:33 Will Barlow Thank you. 38:34 Sean Finnegan Okay. 38:37 Sean Finnegan All right, your 15 minutes begins now. 38:41 Will Barlow Thank you so much, John, for that opening statement. 38:45 Will Barlow I'm looking forward to seeing how this conversation continues. 38:49 Will Barlow I just want to reiterate here at the beginning something very specific. 38:53 Will Barlow My primary concern with the Christadelphian view is exegetical. 38:58 Will Barlow And I noticed in John's opening that we didn't really get into a lot of the New Testament texts, specifically in the Gospels. 39:04 Will Barlow And I'm looking forward to cross-ex. 39:07 Will Barlow Looking forward to digging into some of those texts with John and seeing how he interprets certain important texts. 39:13 Will Barlow Because the truth of the matter is we can both have an explanation. 39:17 Will Barlow I have an explanation for a lot of these texts. 39:19 Will Barlow John has an explanation for all these texts. 39:22 Will Barlow The question isn't, do we have an explanation? 39:24 Will Barlow The question is, what is the best explanation based on all the evidence? 39:29 Will Barlow And again, my concerns very specifically to the Christadelphian view are exegetical in nature. 39:34 Will Barlow And by and large, this is a New Testament question, not an Old Testament question. 39:38 Will Barlow Now, I noticed that John during his presentation offered up a couple of hypothetical philosophical questions about explaining more of the detail behind the devil and demons. 39:49 Will Barlow And if Satan existed in this way, then God would have had to confer him. 39:56 Will Barlow power, but then how does he become evil? 39:57 Will Barlow And if he doesn't, then how can we say he has power at all and things like that. 40:03 Will Barlow And so I just want to say that Christadelphians like John often argue that those who believe in the literal existence of supernatural evil agents should be able to answer every question about these types of things, about origins, about tactics, about how it all works, about how the evil inclination could work together with a supernatural devil, about how temptation could work with a devil. 40:24 Will Barlow And I would say just very simply that there are many doctrines that would fail this test. 40:29 Will Barlow For example, what exactly is Jesus doing today? 40:33 Will Barlow The Bible describes him as having a heavenly ministry. 40:35 Will Barlow We know very little about what that heavenly ministry looks like. 40:39 Will Barlow We're given a couple of texts, Ephesians 5 and a couple other places where it uses present tense verbs for Christ's activity today. 40:47 Will Barlow But I could not give you Christ's day planner. 40:49 Will Barlow I could not tell you how much he intervenes with people. 40:52 Will Barlow I could not, even in a UCA presentation a few years back, consequently tell you with authority whether you can pray to Jesus or not, which is a subject of interest among many Unitarians. 41:01 Will Barlow I think the arguments are divided on that. 41:04 Will Barlow The texts are divided on that. 41:06 Will Barlow And so if we need absolute clarity on everything, this is going to fail this test. 41:11 Will Barlow What about exactly what the kingdom will look like? 41:13 Will Barlow We know that the kingdom will be on earth. 41:15 Will Barlow We have hypothetical ideas of like what farming will look like and what this will look like and what that will look like. 41:21 Will Barlow But we don't know whether we'll have sex or not have sex, whether we'll have things like golf and coffee. 41:29 Will Barlow None of these things are obvious in scripture. 41:32 Will Barlow And so we have to be careful that we don't, I don't need to resolve all the questions on this topic. 41:37 Will Barlow What I need to do is provide evidence, exegetical evidence that the devil and demons exist. 41:41 Will Barlow I think we're going to see that. 41:42 Will Barlow We've already seen it in my opening, and we're going to see it further in cross X. 41:46 Will Barlow Next, I want to drill a little bit into the yetzer hurrah and demons. 41:51 Will Barlow Christadelphians often argue that the yetzer hurrah is found in scripture, including in Genesis 6 and James 1. 41:57 Will Barlow We saw John do that in his opening statement. 41:59 Will Barlow And I'm going to mostly agree with him. 42:01 Will Barlow I would say that while the later rabbinic formulation isn't entirely taught in scripture, I'm going to say the concept is biblical. 42:07 Will Barlow I agree that the evil inclination is biblical. 42:10 Will Barlow I think that this actually makes the argument almost worse, probably worse for the Christadelphians though, because it shows what it documents is the biblical writers had a choice to describe demons this way and explicitly chose not to. 42:23 Will Barlow I want to point out that John quoted a verse in Matthew, a section that we're going to look at later, in several instances in Matthew where we have the devil and demons. 42:33 Will Barlow And so, sure, yeah, the evil inclination may be in Matthew five. 42:36 Will Barlow That's fine. 42:37 Will Barlow But it's also alongside strong devil and demonology texts. 42:41 Will Barlow And so this is a concern for the Christadelphians, I believe. 42:45 Will Barlow And I also want to point out that these two concepts are not mutually exclusive. 42:48 Will Barlow In fact, I think they work quite well together. 42:50 Will Barlow I think that there is a human inclination to sin on some level. 42:54 Will Barlow I don't believe in total depravity like the Calvinists do. 42:57 Will Barlow But I do believe that there is an inclination to sin. 43:01 Will Barlow But I also think that there's external forces at work. 43:04 Will Barlow And so we can say that humans have some inclination to sin and to evil, especially when they're worked on by outside sources, like their environment, like traumas, like the forces of darkness that are in control of our culture and our world. 43:18 Will Barlow And I think that's the biblical worldview in places like Ephesians 6. 43:22 Will Barlow And so, yes, there's more involved here. 43:24 Will Barlow Paul would say yes to all of it. 43:26 Will Barlow Evil inclination, yes. 43:27 Will Barlow Also demonic forces, yes. 43:29 Will Barlow Jesus would say the same thing. 43:30 Will Barlow Evil inclination, yes. 43:32 Will Barlow Demonic forces, yes. 43:34 Will Barlow So they're not mutually exclusive at all. 43:36 Will Barlow And in fact, I want to point out, in Berkot 5A, it says this. 43:42 Will Barlow is part of the Mishnah. 43:44 Will Barlow Incidental to the verse, tremble and do not sin, the Gemera mentions that Rabbi Levi Bar-Hama said that Rabbi Shimon ben Lachish said, 43:51 Will Barlow One should always incite his good inclination against his evil inclination, i.e. 43:55 Will Barlow that one must constantly struggle so that his evil inclination does not lead him to transgression. 44:00 Will Barlow As is stated, tremble and do not sin. 44:03 Will Barlow Well, in the very next tract, 86a, it says, another Baraida, it was taught that Abba bin Yamin says, if the eye was given permission to see, no creature would be able to withstand the abundance and ubiquity of the demons and continue to live unaffected by them. 44:17 Will Barlow So the point here is clear, and from Bear Kote 6A, from this point forward, it goes on to list several other rabbis who taught similarly. 44:25 Will Barlow So I just want to say that there is no conflict between believing in the Yetzer Hurrah and demons. 44:31 Will Barlow In fact, some of the rabbinical sources that indicate belief in the evil incarnation or Yetzer Hurrah actually also show belief in demons at the same time. 44:41 Will Barlow Now I want to talk a little bit about problems with harmonizing doctrine. 44:45 Will Barlow John made a pretty big deal in his opening statement about harmonizing the Old Testament and the New Testament, making sure that we have consistency between the two testaments. 44:54 Will Barlow And particularly he's making a big deal that there is no clear devil or demon doctrine in the Old Testament. 45:00 Will Barlow But I also want to point out that the full Christadelphian version is also not clearly taught anywhere in scripture, much less the Old Testament. 45:06 Will Barlow And again, you can grab pieces here and there. 45:09 Will Barlow You can talk about the evil 45:10 Will Barlow inclination in Genesis 6, and you can talk about it in James. 45:15 Will Barlow You can sort of make pieces here and there, but there is no systematic Christadelphian treatment anywhere in scripture either. 45:21 Will Barlow And so we're sort of both struck with the same kind of problem. 45:25 Will Barlow And I want to say that there are also many other important doctrines that are fleshed out in the New Testament and seem to be relatively unimportant in the Old Testament. 45:34 Will Barlow For example, the death and resurrection of Messiah itself. 45:38 Will Barlow It's not something talked a lot about in the Old Testament. 45:40 Will Barlow But this is a foundational New Testament doctrine. 45:44 Will Barlow And so why do we have this foundational New Testament doctrine that hardly has any ink in the Old Testament? 45:49 Will Barlow Well, I just think that sometimes things get revealed later in the story. 45:53 Will Barlow And there's lots of reasons for that. 45:56 Will Barlow But we could just simply say that there's lots of things that are hidden somewhat. 46:01 Will Barlow What about the difference between the Messiah's first and second coming? 46:04 Will Barlow All these prophecies in Messiah in the Old Testament seem like they're all the same time. 46:08 Will Barlow He's going to come and do this. 46:09 Will Barlow He's going to come and do that. 46:10 Will Barlow He's going to bring the kingdom at the same time as he does all these other things. 46:13 Will Barlow And the light from the New Testament says, nope, actually there's a first coming and then there's a second coming. 46:18 Will Barlow He's going to be Messiah been Joseph first and Messiah been David later. 46:22 Will Barlow And so there have been speculations on that being two separate people. 46:26 Will Barlow It ends up being just one, but two different comings. 46:28 Will Barlow That wasn't clear in the Old Testament. 46:31 Will Barlow How about the New Covenant? 46:32 Will Barlow That the New Covenant would exist was in Old Testament theology. 46:35 Will Barlow The specifics of the New Covenant, how it worked, the stipulations, when it would be inaugurated, when it would be consummated, all those details, those all get fleshed out in the New Testament. 46:46 Will Barlow What about the salvation of the Gentiles as full covenant community members? 46:49 Will Barlow There's tons of prophetic passages talking about how the Gentiles will come into Jerusalem, they're gonna worship with the people of God, all this stuff's gonna be great, but they don't flush out the full salvation of Gentiles as full covenant community members until it seems like Jesus knows it and Paul reveals it in the epistles. 47:06 Will Barlow What about the resurrection of the dead in eternal life? 47:09 Will Barlow So all these things, all these things are fleshed out in the New Testament and relatively unimportant in the Old Testament. 47:16 Will Barlow Now I want to bring up one final thing, and that we didn't really come up too much in John's opening, but I just sort of want to head this off at the past, that there's a historical argument that often gets made that a lot of this belief in the devil and demons comes in during the Second Temple Jewish period after the Persian 47:33 Will Barlow exile, the Persian period in Jewish history. 47:36 Will Barlow And I just want to say that this claim is very interesting to me because what we would say, the history of the Hebrews is full of idolatry, full of not strict monotheism until after the exile, right? 47:50 Will Barlow And so if the belief in devil and demons comes after the exile, and if belief in one God in a strict monotheistic way also comes after the exile, 48:01 Will Barlow then the conclusion is belief in the devil and demons does not contradict strict monotheism. 48:06 Will Barlow That's the only conclusion that we can reach historically. 48:09 Will Barlow And so I want to make that point very clearly here. 48:12 Will Barlow Now, I want to also ask a question about monism, monotheism, or monolatry. 48:17 Will Barlow This is an interesting question. 48:18 Will Barlow My friend Dr. 48:19 Will Barlow Dustin Smith recently did a podcast on this in the Biblical Unitarian podcast, so I'm indebted to him for some of this information, but I want to say with John that I agree that there's one supreme God. 48:30 Will Barlow The ancient Israelites, however, almost always, unfortunately, worshipped other gods alongside Yahweh. 48:36 Will Barlow And the Bible portrays supernatural beings at odds with God. 48:39 Will Barlow And I just want to give some examples of this. 48:42 Will Barlow So in Deuteronomy 4, it talks about the host of heaven being given to the nations of the world to serve. 48:49 Will Barlow And the people of God were not to serve them. 48:53 Will Barlow Yahweh has allotted to the people's 48:57 Will Barlow these other gods. 48:59 Will Barlow And that's Deuteronomy 4. 49:01 Will Barlow In Deuteronomy 10, it says, Yahweh your God is God of gods and Lord of lords. 49:07 Will Barlow This implicitly assumes that there are other Elohim, that there are other supernatural beings. 49:12 Will Barlow And my dialogue partner, I suppose, might say that these are all positive things, but the fact is that many times this word Elohim also refers to these 49:20 Will Barlow false gods in the Old Testament. 49:23 Will Barlow In Deuteronomy 29, it says that God brought his people out of the land of Egypt, but then after he did that, they went and served other gods and worshiped them, gods whom they had not known and whom he had not allotted to them. 49:36 Will Barlow So again, we see this over and over again. 49:40 Will Barlow In Psalm 82, it says, you are gods. 49:42 Will Barlow And this is debatable because Jesus interprets this to refer to human judges, but the initial context seems to be more along the lines 49:50 Will Barlow of supernatural beings being referred to in Psalm 82. 49:54 Will Barlow In Psalm 97, it says, Worship Him, all you gods. 49:57 Will Barlow You're exalted far above all gods. 49:59 Will Barlow In Psalm 136, it calls God again, the God of gods. 50:03 Will Barlow In Psalm 138, it says, I will sing praises to you before the gods. 50:08 Will Barlow And a lot of times the Septuagint will render these with the word for angel. 50:13 Will Barlow So again, we see this idea perhaps of supernatural beings being called Elohim and being interpreted by the Septuagint as angels. 50:22 Will Barlow These are supernatural beings perhaps called gods or evil, but these are absolutely existing. 50:29 Will Barlow When we get to the New Testament, Jesus says, you shall worship the Lord your God and him only shall you serve. 50:35 Will Barlow So Proskuneo can go to a number of people. 50:37 Will Barlow Proskuneo can go to the human king. 50:39 Will Barlow Proskuneo can go to a superior human. 50:42 Will Barlow But him only shall you letreo, manos letreo, where we get the term monolatry from. 50:47 Will Barlow And again, I'm not saying I believe in monolatry. 50:49 Will Barlow I'm just pointing out the etymology. 50:52 Will Barlow In 1 Corinthians 8, Paul says, there are many gods and many lords, yet for us there is one God, the Father. 50:58 Will Barlow In 2 Corinthians 4, he calls something, someone, the god of this world or age, and they're blinding the minds. 51:06 Will Barlow That'd be another great text to talk about. 51:08 Will Barlow Second Corinthians 11, I talked about this when Satan disguised himself as an angel of light. 51:12 Will Barlow Ephesians 6, I talked about this in my opening statement. 51:15 Will Barlow You've got rulers, you've got authorities, you've got cosmic powers, spiritual forces of evil in the heavenly places. 51:22 Will Barlow So this is not dualism with two equal powers. 51:24 Will Barlow This is what I would call either monotheism or monolatry, and I think you can take your pick on the terminology. 51:31 Will Barlow Now, John also claimed during his opening that demons are always idols in Paul, just like the Septuagint handles relevant Old Testament texts. 51:39 Will Barlow But I would say the truth is more complicated than that. 51:42 Will Barlow First, Luke describes Paul casting out a demon in Acts 16. 51:47 Will Barlow And it says, you know, he said to the spirit, I command you in the name of Jesus Christ to come out of her. 51:52 Will Barlow And it came out of her that very hour. 51:54 Will Barlow So the idea that Paul would be teaching something unrelated to his experience in Acts 16 seems strange to me. 52:01 Will Barlow When we get to Paul's discussion of demons in 1 Corinthians 10, I think some interesting things come up. 52:06 Will Barlow It says, what do I imply then, that food offered to idols is anything or that an idol is anything? 52:11 Will Barlow No, I imply that what pagans sacrifice they offer to demons and not to God. 52:17 Will Barlow He doesn't say they don't exist. 52:18 Will Barlow He says idols are not real, but demons are. 52:21 Will Barlow He says, I do not want you to be participants with demons. 52:25 Will Barlow You cannot drink of the cup of the Lord and the cup of demons. 52:29 Will Barlow So in 1 Corinthians 10, Paul explicitly says that Gentiles sacrifice to demons. 52:35 Will Barlow He describes those who participate in those sacrifices as becoming participants with the demons. 52:40 Will Barlow So the natural mainstream conclusion is that Paul regards demons as actual recipients of pagan sacrifices. 52:47 Will Barlow Now of course, this doesn't preclude the other activities of demons found in the Gospels and in Acts. 52:53 Will Barlow I want to say a few words. 52:55 Will Barlow Thank you, Sean. 52:56 Will Barlow I want to say a couple things about the accommodation argument. 52:58 Will Barlow John didn't talk about this very much, but I do want to sort of head some of these things off with the pass. 53:03 Will Barlow I'm generally fine with accommodation arguments, but I don't disagree in principle, but I disagree with this specific accommodation argument. 53:11 Will Barlow I've got a couple reasons for it. 53:13 Will Barlow One, Jesus didn't merely use familiar terminology. 53:16 Will Barlow He taught about Satan and extended explanations. 53:19 Will Barlow He does this 53:21 Will Barlow all the time. 53:23 Will Barlow Number 2, his actions and exorcisms go beyond simply accommodating someone's vocabulary. 53:28 Will Barlow We're going to get into this in cross X on Mark 5. 53:32 Will Barlow He also has private teaching to his disciples that reinforces rather than corrects the personal understanding of Satan. 53:39 Will Barlow The New Testament also continues to teach about Satan and demons after Jesus' resurrection. 53:45 Will Barlow And the final thing I would ask is if the accommodation theory is true, there must be an independent reason, not just an assumption that it could be true. 53:52 Will Barlow And so I'm eager to explore all this with John more as the debate continues. 53:56 Will Barlow Thank you very much. 53:59 Sean Finnegan But I'm going to pass it over to John for his 15 minutes. 54:02 Sean Finnegan John, it's your turn, starting now. 54:07 Jon Burke Thanks very much, Sean. 54:09 Jon Burke Will made some points which I'd like to respond to, and I'd like to thank him again for establishing some common ground. 54:16 Jon Burke I agree that the New Testament does reveal foundational gospel doctrines which were not explicit in the Old Testament. 54:24 Jon Burke However, when it does so, it explicitly explains how they were foreshadowed in the Old Testament and does so repeatedly with reference to Old Testament scriptures. 54:35 Jon Burke But the New Testament never does this of Satan and demons. 54:41 Jon Burke Just on the point of identifying demons with the evil inclination, I wouldn't identify demons with the evil inclination. 54:49 Jon Burke And I do insist that the Old and New Testament both define demons when they do define them literally as the imaginary gods of the heathen. 54:58 Jon Burke And to me, that's an explicit definition, which is strict monotheism, and it's as early as Deuteronomy 55:04 Jon Burke not simply in the exilic or post-exilic period. 55:08 Jon Burke The real question is, although we know that the Jews at times worship other gods, which they believed were real, does the Bible portray the gods of the heathen as real or not? 55:21 Jon Burke Is there one God or are there many gods? 55:24 Jon Burke Do we have options? 55:26 Jon Burke Are there any other gods? 55:28 Jon Burke Do we believe simply in monolatry, that there are many gods from which we could choose, and that these are all independent divine beings, and of whom God is only one and perhaps the greatest, but still only an option? 55:43 Jon Burke Or is there only one God? 55:45 Jon Burke To me, this is fundamental to biblical Unitarianism. 55:49 Jon Burke There is one God and one Lord, Jesus Christ, as Paul said. 55:55 Jon Burke Now, I was interested to see that Will mentioned that the Elohim which he cited in Psalms, identified as angels or angelos in the Septuagint, were identified as humans by Jesus. 56:11 Jon Burke And if Jesus identifies these Elohim as humans, then I don't see any motivation for disagreeing with Jesus and 56:19 Jon Burke identifying them as something else. 56:21 Jon Burke Again, are they real gods who exist alongside Yahweh? 56:26 Jon Burke And likewise, when Paul speaks of these demons, does he really say that these demons are actually real pagan gods who exist alongside God and that, in fact, Paul was not a monotheist, that he believed in many gods? 56:41 Jon Burke No, I believe Paul said that there is one God and although that to the pagans there were many gods, to us there 56:47 Jon Burke is one God and one Lord Jesus. 56:51 Jon Burke Now, this is a question I think which is fundamental. 56:55 Jon Burke Do we believe in monotheism or do we not? 56:59 Jon Burke Now, if you want to interpret demons as the souls of dead men, as say Josephus and Philo did, or if you want to interpret them as some form of evil, supernatural being which is 57:13 Jon Burke something more like a demigod or a semi-small divine being, then you would have to argue for that and find where the Bible defines them as that. 57:22 Jon Burke But to me, I find the Old and New Testament unite in saying that demons are merely the false gods of the heathen which do not exist. 57:31 Jon Burke Now, since there's a clear background for Satan and demons, the terms of Satan and devil 57:38 Jon Burke in Second Temple period literature before the New Testament being used as a personification of the evil inclination, how do we prove that these references in the New Testament to Satan and demons, or to Satan and the devil rather, refer to supernatural evil and not simply a perpetuation or continuation of a personification of 58:03 Jon Burke the evil inclination. 58:05 Jon Burke I think that's a point I'd like to see we'll explore. 58:09 Jon Burke To my mind, when speaking explicitly on the process of temptation and sin, I don't find Jesus and the New Testament writers using Satan as an explanation. 58:22 Jon Burke I have here the homatology, the explanation of temptation and sin of Jesus. 58:28 Jon Burke compared to what's called the cosmological and forensic view. 58:31 Jon Burke The cosmological view of sin identifies temptation and sin as having a predominantly supernatural evil origin. 58:37 Jon Burke The forensic view identifies temptation and sin as having a human origin. 58:42 Jon Burke And very importantly, although I fully accept that there is a sense in which you could marry these two, you could hold both of these together, 58:51 Jon Burke I believe that the New Testament doesn't teach that these are two parts of the explanation for temptation and sin. 58:59 Jon Burke When Jesus teaches about the origin of evil and sin, he does so going straight to Cain, who was, of course, the murderer in Genesis. 59:10 Jon Burke He doesn't reference Adam, Eve, or even the serpent in Genesis 3. 59:14 Jon Burke He says the contemporary cause of sin is the human heart or human adversaries. 59:21 Jon Burke And he says the remedy for sin is self-discipline, supplicatory prayer and law observance. 59:26 Jon Burke This is the so-called forensic view of temptation and sin, which identifies as having a human origin. 59:31 Jon Burke Again, when Jesus explicitly teaches on the process of temptation and sin, I don't find him invoking 59:39 Jon Burke more than one view. 59:41 Jon Burke That is, oh, it comes from your heart and there's a separate evil supernatural being. 59:47 Jon Burke Likewise, I find Paul saying the same. 59:50 Jon Burke Paul, some archeology, identifies the origin of evil and sin with Adam's sin in Eden and the serpent's deception of Eve. 59:58 Jon Burke And of course, as Will says, well, yes, he does say the serpent. 1:00:02 Jon Burke If we believe the serpent there really means a supernatural evil being, how do we know this? 1:00:07 Jon Burke Because Paul doesn't say 1:00:09 Jon Burke that. 1:00:09 Jon Burke And of course, nobody says that until the second century, in the middle of the second century with Justin Martyr. 1:00:16 Jon Burke Paul identifies the contemporary cause of sin as the human heart and human adversaries, and the remedy for sin as self-discipline, fellow Christians help, and supplicatory prayer from God. 1:00:25 Jon Burke Again, this is the forensic view of sin, not the cosmological. 1:00:29 Jon Burke Paul doesn't invoke supernatural evil beings as well as 1:00:34 Jon Burke the evil inclination. 1:00:38 Jon Burke Now, I think there are a number of passages which are extremely difficult to interpret as anything other than Satan and the devil in the New Testament referring to human agency, either the evil inclination or people. 1:00:53 Jon Burke In Matthew 16, 23, when Christ says, get behind me, Satan, Peter is the Satan. 1:00:59 Jon Burke He's a human Satan. 1:01:01 Jon Burke He's a human adversary, just like we see in the Old Testament. 1:01:04 Jon Burke As I said previously, in Acts 5:3, Peter tells Ananias that Satan has filled his heart, which he explains with the parallelism that you have contrived this deed in your heart, identifying the Satan as Ananias' own evil inclination. 1:01:17 Jon Burke This is a continuation of the personification of the evil inclination, which first emerged in the Old Testament, was personified in the Second Temple period, and is continued in the New Testament. 1:01:30 Jon Burke Certain New Testament passages are, I believe, very difficult to reconcile to with a supernatural evil being called Satan who opposes God and all his works. 1:01:40 Jon Burke 5 and 1 Timothy 1:20, why does Paul command that people be handed over to Satan to correct them? 1:01:47 Jon Burke 7, what is that messenger of Satan sent by God apparently to Paul? 1:01:52 Jon Burke in order to correct him. 1:01:56 Jon Burke Scholarly literature agrees that Jesus did not share first century Palestinian demonology, not only because he never defines demons or treats demons in the same way that they do, but his methods of exorcism in particular were radically different. 1:02:11 Jon Burke Very importantly, 1:02:14 Jon Burke Ferngren says the gospels don't record either Jesus or the gospels write its explanation of demonic possession. 1:02:19 Jon Burke They simply write of it in a phenomenalistic view. 1:02:22 Jon Burke That is what people experienced and saw. 1:02:25 Jon Burke I think it's very interesting that scholars also recognize that Luke, the physician, characterizes exorcisms as healing. 1:02:34 Jon Burke He speaks of people being healed of evil spirits in Luke, Acts 2. 1:02:38 Jon Burke Likewise, Acts 19:12, their diseases left them and 1:02:41 Jon Burke And the parallelism, the evil spirits went out of them. 1:02:45 Jon Burke And of course, Psalm 103, he is the one who forgives all your sins, who heals all your diseases, is invoked in Isaiah. 1:02:54 Jon Burke And of course, in Matthew 8 16, when it was many evening, many demon possessed people were brought to him. 1:02:59 Jon Burke He drove out the spirits without a word and healed all who were sick. 1:03:02 Jon Burke And Matthew says, this fulfilled the scripture. 1:03:04 Jon Burke He took our weaknesses and carried our diseases, a parallelism which I think is pretty clear. 1:03:11 Jon Burke Of course, it's well recognized that in John in particular, Satan has a minimalist role, which is why some commentators believe John's devil is a literary personification of sin. 1:03:23 Jon Burke And John Christopher Thomas likewise notes, neither James nor John, when they talk about illness or disease, don't attribute it to Satan or demons. 1:03:32 Jon Burke We find that Dunn and 123, even though they do believe in supernatural evil, 1:03:37 Jon Burke They believe that the New Testament writers had no clear conceptualization of particular entities and agree there is no clear concept of demons found in the gospels other than the gods, the heathen. 1:03:48 Jon Burke They even acknowledge that passages such as Mark 9 are examples of pre-scientific explanations for illnesses we now understand, even though they say that they may behind them be a demonic cause of the illness. 1:03:59 Jon Burke It's very noticeable. 1:04:01 Jon Burke that we find demons referred to almost exclusively in the synoptics. 1:04:09 Jon Burke Why are demons almost completely absent from texts written to mature Christians? 1:04:12 Jon Burke Why do neither Jesus nor Paul diagnose anyone with demonic possession? 1:04:17 Jon Burke And why does Paul not describe the office of exorcist or exorcism as a gift of the Spirit? 1:04:24 Jon Burke This has been noted many times by scholars. 1:04:26 Jon Burke Why did John disregard Jesus' exorcisms? 1:04:29 Jon Burke It's well noted that over time, not only in the New Testament, but in early Christianity, interest in exorcism declined and it vanishes until the mid 2nd century. 1:04:40 Jon Burke Here's my explanation. 1:04:41 Jon Burke In John's gospel for mature believers, we find the blind, the lame, the withered, the sick, the impotent, suffering from infirmity or suffering from disease, but not suffering from demonic possession or evil spirits. 1:04:53 Jon Burke The Synoptics were preaching aids for potential converts and immature Christians. 1:04:57 Jon Burke They were catechetical devices, as is well recognized by mainstream scholarship. 1:05:02 Jon Burke John's gospel, in contrast, written for mature Christians, contains no belief in demons. 1:05:07 Jon Burke And outside, of course, the Synoptics, there's hardly any reference to demons at all other than as the 1:05:13 Jon Burke and defined by Paul and Revelation as the false gods of the heathen. 1:05:18 Jon Burke And it's recognized, of course, by scholars that reference in the New Testament epistles in particular to demonia, demons, is limited to just four verses. 1:05:26 Jon Burke And remember that passage in Acts with the woman who had an evil spirit cast out by Paul, 1:05:34 Jon Burke Remember, Paul did not diagnose her as having a demon, and the word for the evil spirit there is not the word demon. 1:05:41 Jon Burke It is not described as a demon. 1:05:43 Jon Burke It is described as the spirit of Python, who was, of course, an oracle at Delphi, a belief in a supernatural oracle at Delphi, not a demon possessing the woman or inflicting her with sickness. 1:05:58 Jon Burke In fact, granting her the gift of 1:06:01 Jon Burke foresight or prophecy, as it was understood. 1:06:07 Jon Burke Now, do I have a few more minutes, Sean? 1:06:12 Sean Finnegan Yep, you have about three more minutes. 1:06:15 Jon Burke Okay, great. 1:06:16 Jon Burke Excellent. 1:06:16 Jon Burke Thanks for that. 1:06:18 Jon Burke So in my view, in particular, when Jesus and Paul, especially, 1:06:25 Jon Burke are defining and describing the process of temptation and sin, they never have recourse to supernatural evil beings. 1:06:35 Jon Burke If this was an important doctrine to be revealed in the New Testament, as with other important elements of the gospel, then why is it not explained there? 1:06:43 Jon Burke Why are we never told it was implicit or foreshadowed in the Old Testament, just like all the other doctrines on which we don't have a lot of information? 1:06:51 Jon Burke I grant Will that he doesn't have to explain everything about Satan and demons, just like we don't know everything about certain doctrines which we are taught in the New Testament. 1:07:01 Jon Burke But we are taught something and we are taught explicitly that these doctrines are true. 1:07:06 Jon Burke And we even showed when they were foreshadowed in the Old Testament that they were foreshadowed. 1:07:10 Jon Burke And we are shown their doctrinal roots in the Old Testament. 1:07:15 Jon Burke But the New Testament never actually does that. 1:07:19 Jon Burke We're never given this new revelation. 1:07:21 Jon Burke I think that Will is unintentionally using the same strategy which is used to defend the doctrine of the Trinity, the doctrine of the immortal soul, and the doctrine of immortal souls burning forever in hell. 1:07:39 Jon Burke To my mind, there's very clear explicit definition of what demons are, that they are the false gods, the heathen, and they do not exist. 1:07:47 Jon Burke To my mind, it's also clear that the New Testament as a whole reflects a very clear doctrinal teaching to mature Christians, which completely omits reference to evil spirits or demons or demonic possession or exorcism. 1:08:03 Jon Burke These simply aren't referred to in writings for mature Christians, because these are not necessary. 1:08:10 Jon Burke When James talks about healing the sick, he calls for prayer and anointing with oil, never an exorcism, nor does Paul in any of his writings. 1:08:19 Jon Burke I believe also that the New Testament pattern is very consistent in supporting the Old Testament teaching on these positions. 1:08:29 Jon Burke I would also like to raise again the fact that although Will started his analysis of post-New Testament Christian thought in the mid-second century, the Didache stands there as the earliest systematic Christian witness to treatment of temptation and sin. 1:08:50 Jon Burke and not only never once has recourse to Satan or demons or the devil or any other evil spirits, but actually explicitly rejects them and identifies the source of temptation and sin in the human heart or with human opponents. 1:09:07 Sean Finnegan That will draw to an end our rebuttals and we can move on then just to show you where we're at here. 1:09:16 Sean Finnegan Yeah, so we've done the opening statements. 1:09:19 Sean Finnegan We've done the rebuttals. 1:09:21 Sean Finnegan And so now we are ready for cross examinations. 1:09:25 Sean Finnegan This is the spicy part. 1:09:28 Sean Finnegan A lot of excitement here. 1:09:29 Sean Finnegan We can hear first from Will asking his questions. 1:09:35 Sean Finnegan And I'll bring all of us on here together. 1:09:39 Sean Finnegan Will will be asking his questions for 15 minutes. 1:09:42 Sean Finnegan And John, I would just ask that you do your best to be brief in your answers. 1:09:49 Sean Finnegan so that Will can get through multiple questions in the allotted time. 1:09:54 Sean Finnegan Are you ready to go, Will? 1:09:55 Will Barlow I'm ready. 1:09:56 Will Barlow Thanks, Sean. 1:09:56 Sean Finnegan All right, your 15 minutes begins now. 1:09:59 Will Barlow All right, John, I want to ask you a couple of sort of clarifying questions to begin. 1:10:03 Will Barlow The first one is, let's suppose, like I do, that I believe in a supernatural devil and demons. 1:10:09 Will Barlow But let's say, and I don't know if this is true or not, but I probably agree with most of your statement of faith. 1:10:13 Will Barlow Let's say I agreed with your entire statement of faith, except for the provision on devil and demons. 1:10:19 Will Barlow Would I be able to take communion in a Christadelphian ecclesia? 1:10:22 Will Barlow Ecclesia. 1:10:26 Will Barlow Oh, you're muted, John. 1:10:27 Will Barlow Sorry. 1:10:30 Jon Burke Sorry. 1:10:30 Jon Burke Thanks for letting me know. 1:10:31 Jon Burke Yeah, I have to be honest and say it depends. 1:10:34 Jon Burke There are Christian Ecclesias which would accept that as long as you don't teach it because they believe that's the biblical model. 1:10:41 Jon Burke Because Paul, as is well recognized, accommodated some people who were weak in the faith. 1:10:47 Jon Burke And it's very clear when he actually says, look, there are Christians who still think that eating 1:10:52 Jon Burke Meat offered to idols is a big deal. 1:10:53 Jon Burke We know idols aren't anything. 1:10:55 Jon Burke We know that the gods of the heathen don't exist, but in some people there is not yet that faith, but he still brought them to the table of communion. 1:11:04 Jon Burke Other Christian congregations would be more strict. 1:11:06 Jon Burke I side with Paul on that. 1:11:08 Jon Burke I hope that helps answer your question. 1:11:10 Will Barlow And you take me as a brother in Christ, correct? 1:11:12 Will Barlow That I'm saved. 1:11:17 Jon Burke Yes, I do. 1:11:18 Jon Burke And I believe that when it comes to imperfect belief, and I'm certainly sure that I have some imperfect belief, although I strongly believe that the correct belief in Satan and demons is an essential part of the gospel, it's for God to judge exactly what level of imperfect faith 1:11:37 Jon Burke is required. 1:11:38 Jon Burke And of course, I don't believe that judgment is a doctrinal test alone. 1:11:41 Jon Burke I'm sure we both agree with this. 1:11:44 Will Barlow Yes, I'm thankful that that's not the case as well. 1:11:46 Will Barlow I don't believe I have it all right. 1:11:49 Will Barlow So let me ask you this. 1:11:50 Will Barlow When something evil happens, do you believe it's always caused by God? 1:11:58 Jon Burke Well, that's a good question because 1:12:00 Jon Burke Remember when the, as Jesus said, when these Galileans who were punished, all the people on whom the wall fell, do you believe that those people were more evil than others and so God was punishing them? 1:12:21 Jon Burke And yeah, Jesus says, no, it doesn't work like that. 1:12:25 Jon Burke I don't believe that evil in the world is always uniquely attributable to God. 1:12:34 Jon Burke I don't believe it's always uniquely attributable to humans. 1:12:37 Jon Burke I believe that God, firstly, I believe that God permits certain things to happen. 1:12:42 Jon Burke I believe that obviously, especially in the past, God has invoked his own divine power to create 1:12:48 Jon Burke certain evils as punishments on Sodom and Gambara, for example, and has used the weather in particular and the natural forces in order to bring about those kinds of disasters. 1:13:00 Jon Burke But I also believe that the natural order itself has a kind of cost of creation. 1:13:06 Jon Burke The electromagnetic field from which we benefit is generated by the Earth's molten magnetic core rotating inside itself, but that 1:13:13 Jon Burke in turn generates earthquakes and volcanoes. 1:13:16 Jon Burke Now we don't like earthquakes and volcanoes, but we would like it a lot less if there was no magnetosphere, which would result in us being toasted completely to a crisp by the sun. 1:13:27 Jon Burke So I don't believe it's as simple as God causes every form of evil or humans do either. 1:13:34 Will Barlow Let me ask you about Job specifically. 1:13:36 Will Barlow Do you think Job's calamity was caused by God? 1:13:38 Will Barlow Do you take the human 1:13:40 Will Barlow I guess, view on that, the human opposer, or do you take a righteous angel? 1:13:46 Jon Burke I do take the human view because I think it's more consistent, but I am sympathetic to the righteous angel view. 1:13:54 Jon Burke To my mind, it's significant that not only does the Satan request power from God or permission from God to inflict evil on Job, but the book of Job explicitly says that it is God who carries out 1:14:10 Jon Burke these acts. 1:14:11 Jon Burke And not only that, but Job himself only knows God as the origin of his evils. 1:14:17 Jon Burke He doesn't seem to know about a supernatural evil being called Satan, which to my mind is significant because if he doesn't know, then why would we believe in such a thing? 1:14:28 Jon Burke And if Satan here is requesting permission from God and Job believes that all these evils are brought to him by God as a test, 1:14:37 Jon Burke then why should I believe anything else? 1:14:40 Will Barlow Let me ask you, the illnesses that Jesus heals in the gospels, would you say that those are caused by environmental factors or caused by God or what's your take on the illnesses that Jesus heals? 1:14:56 Jon Burke Well, I think that, well, for example, 1:15:01 Jon Burke The disciples actually asked Jesus a very similar question. 1:15:04 Jon Burke What result? 1:15:05 Jon Burke Why is this man afflicted? 1:15:07 Jon Burke Is it because he sinned or his parents sinned? 1:15:10 Jon Burke And of course, Jesus said, look, again, it's not like that. 1:15:13 Jon Burke Just because somebody sinned is in a bad situation, just because they have an affliction, it's not necessarily God punishing them. 1:15:21 Jon Burke And I think that's got deep implications for how we treat 1:15:25 Jon Burke how we treat people, just as an aside. 1:15:27 Jon Burke But I believe that there are quite possibly situations in which God may or that an illness may have been a product of God, but we're just not told of any. 1:15:38 Jon Burke In fact, Jesus tends to head that off. 1:15:40 Jon Burke And again, he doesn't say, oh no, no, no, you don't understand. 1:15:44 Jon Burke God's not punishing him for sin. 1:15:46 Jon Burke Satan is punishing him or a demon afflicted him. 1:15:49 Jon Burke I don't find Jesus ever diagnosing someone as afflicted 1:15:54 Jon Burke by demonic position. 1:15:55 Jon Burke And I do think that's significant. 1:15:58 Will Barlow In 2 Corinthians 4.4, do you agree with Heser that the god of this world blinding the hearts of the unrepentant is doing so at the behest of God under God's authority? 1:16:10 Jon Burke No, I'm not actually familiar with his view on that. 1:16:13 Jon Burke I'm more familiar with Wesley Carr's view in the 1:16:16 Jon Burke in Angels and Principalities, which is one of the standard works on the discussion of the heavenly powers. 1:16:24 Jon Burke And although unfortunately we don't have time to go into that, there's a lot of literature on the identification of what those powers are. 1:16:32 Jon Burke There's been endless discussion, but it is very clear that there is a Jewish 1:16:38 Jon Burke precedent and a general agreement that it is at least a credible view that these are a spiritualized or figurative depiction of the pagan rulership of the time, that the pantocrat or either the Roman Empire or the Roman Emperor itself, which of course is expanded on massively in Revelation, which practically every main scholar agrees 1:17:03 Jon Burke is ultimately, penultimately, the expression of the Roman Empire as the Satan, as the devil, and as the serpent. 1:17:14 Will Barlow These 2 hopefully will be pretty easy. 1:17:16 Will Barlow Do you believe in the inspiration of scripture? 1:17:19 Jon Burke Yep, indisputably. 1:17:20 Will Barlow Yep. 1:17:20 Will Barlow And then do you believe that the gospels relay historical facts about Jesus' life and the events surrounding his life? 1:17:27 Jon Burke Yes, I do. 1:17:28 Jon Burke In either phenomenological terms, occasionally in figurative terms. 1:17:32 Jon Burke Yeah. 1:17:32 Jon Burke And just in the same way that as we would both agree, when Jesus used the parable of Lazarus, he was describing something which very much sounded like a literal event of people going to a literal, yeah, heaven or hell. 1:17:47 Jon Burke But we know that's not what he meant. 1:17:49 Jon Burke And that's one of the reasons why I believe the gospels describe things in a phenomenological way or accommodate certain beliefs because they 1:17:56 Jon Burke catechetical documents. 1:17:57 Jon Burke And I think that John's gospel, written later, written for mature Christians, is remarkable in its absence of that material. 1:18:05 Will Barlow Yeah, I want to ask, I was going to ask about that. 1:18:07 Will Barlow I'm glad you brought that up naturally, that Matthew through Luke is a catechism of sorts for the early church. 1:18:14 Will Barlow I agree with you, actually. 1:18:15 Will Barlow I don't know why Sir Anthony 1:18:19 Will Barlow argued against that in his debate with you on this subject. 1:18:23 Will Barlow But I just want to ask you a follow-up question on that then. 1:18:26 Will Barlow If, let me ask sort of like this. 1:18:30 Will Barlow Could you imagine a universe in which the Christadelphian Catechism, I'm assuming you have something like that, would include something that would accommodate the culture of the time that was factually incorrect? 1:18:40 Will Barlow For example, like 1:18:41 Will Barlow that you would say, it's okay for you to sleep with people that aren't your husband or your wife. 1:18:45 Will Barlow And then later you just teach something else. 1:18:48 Will Barlow Can you imagine the Christadelphian Catechism working that way? 1:18:52 Jon Burke No, I can't, mainly because especially on those specific issues, there are pretty strong statements in Scripture that they are 1:19:05 Jon Burke they are forbidden. 1:19:06 Jon Burke And in fact, even Paul, when of course, as we know when he's talking about the appointments of the deacons and the presbyters, well, he mentions that you must be the husband of one wife. 1:19:17 Jon Burke Sure, sure. 1:19:18 Jon Burke And I do know what you're getting at. 1:19:21 Jon Burke And in Christadelphian missionary experience, naturally in places like Africa and Asia, some other places where we do run into strong 1:19:32 Jon Burke police in supernatural evil. 1:19:36 Jon Burke In some cases, there is a tendency, not to put it in a catechism, and I don't believe that, and again, I don't believe that the gospels ever actually teach, oh, let me explain. 1:19:49 Jon Burke You're ill because you're possessed by a demon. 1:19:52 Jon Burke Again, I don't find that Jesus actually ever says that, which is why I wouldn't think put that in our catechetical material. 1:19:59 Jon Burke Rather, they speak of the 1:20:01 Jon Burke the event phenomenologically as the understanding of the people required. 1:20:06 Jon Burke For example, if you're going to try and convince people Jesus and God are more powerful than your gods, you have to say, well, let's talk about your gods. 1:20:16 Jon Burke If you're going to say, well, if someone says, well, here's somebody who is possessed by what we understand in our culture as an evil spirit. 1:20:24 Jon Burke And you say, evil spirits don't exist, have this injection instead. 1:20:28 Jon Burke It's just a disease. 1:20:31 Jon Burke A better way to be able to say, well, I believe that Jesus is more powerful and I believe that, bring your demon-possessed person and I will heal them. 1:20:43 Jon Burke But I would have to say, bring your demon-possessed person because they would differentiate between people they believe are demonically possessed. 1:20:50 Jon Burke and people they believe are suffering from physical afflictions. 1:20:53 Jon Burke So I'd have to use the language that they use, phenomenologically at least. 1:20:58 Will Barlow Sure. 1:20:59 Will Barlow I'm going to pull up my screen here. 1:21:01 Will Barlow Hopefully, maybe Sean can add it. 1:21:05 Will Barlow Thanks, Sean. 1:21:05 Will Barlow I want to talk about Mark 5. 1:21:07 Will Barlow Can you see this well, John, or do you need to make it bigger? 1:21:12 Jon Burke If you can enlarge it a little, that would be great. 1:21:17 Jon Burke There we go. 1:21:18 Jon Burke I mean, I'm familiar with the passage. 1:21:20 Will Barlow I'm sure you are familiar. 1:21:22 Will Barlow I'm sure, yeah. 1:21:23 Will Barlow So, do you believe that this is a historical event, or do you agree with Heaster that this is a fable? 1:21:30 Jon Burke No, I believe it's a historical event, but I believe it's described phenomenologically. 1:21:35 Jon Burke And for example, that's why, again, if you're going to convince people 1:21:40 Jon Burke And again, this is Mark's gospel, the simplest of the catechetical gospels. 1:21:45 Jon Burke If you're going to convince people that Jesus could heal demoniacs, then this is how he would describe it. 1:21:53 Jon Burke I think it's important that the pronouns switch from I to we. 1:21:56 Jon Burke And I would like to know how many people did Jesus hear? 1:21:59 Jon Burke Did he hear one person or did he hear many voices? 1:22:02 Will Barlow Well, I'm happy to continue talking about this text. 1:22:05 Will Barlow if you want to talk about it more. 1:22:07 Will Barlow But I have a couple of specific questions about this passage. 1:22:10 Will Barlow This mentions supernatural strength and supernatural knowledge of who Jesus was. 1:22:15 Will Barlow I want to ask you specifically, do you agree with Heaster that the physical strength is like a high stress response, perhaps, like a woman picking up a car where her kid's trapped? 1:22:27 Will Barlow Is that your explanation for the supernatural strength? 1:22:29 Will Barlow Just a yes or no. 1:22:32 Jon Burke Yes, because I don't see that the gospel here says it's a supernatural strength or that he was supernaturally empowered by a demon. 1:22:39 Jon Burke So I'm taking a minimalist approach based on what is not said. 1:22:44 Will Barlow The knowledge piece Heaster explains by saying this man had met Jesus before. 1:22:48 Will Barlow Do you agree with that view? 1:22:49 Will Barlow Yes or no? 1:22:51 Jon Burke I don't think there's evidence for that. 1:22:55 Jon Burke I don't think that that's necessary. 1:22:58 Jon Burke I don't think that's necessary since there were plenty of people who believed, even, for example, a Roman centurion who believed that Jesus was the Son of the Most High. 1:23:08 Jon Burke And I don't believe that centurion had met Jesus personally. 1:23:11 Will Barlow Right, so you think it's just his fame spread, basically, that that's why this guy knew this stuff? 1:23:15 Jon Burke Yeah, I think it's difficult to make a solid argument 1:23:20 Jon Burke based on what isn't there. 1:23:22 Jon Burke So that's why I would disagree with his view. 1:23:25 Jon Burke I think he's going one step beyond the text. 1:23:27 Jon Burke But I don't see that there's like taking, using Occam's razor, I don't see the necessity to say, oh, well, a supernatural evil being specifically said to the man he was afflicting, you need to know that's Jesus, the Son of God, he's the Messiah, he's the Lord, and you should obey him just like I should obey him, and I'm going to ask him to help me. 1:23:49 Jon Burke I don't see that as consistent with what demons are supposed to do. 1:23:55 Jon Burke It seems to be a demon converting or preaching the gospel to me. 1:24:00 Will Barlow Sure. 1:24:00 Will Barlow I think there's interesting reasons for that. 1:24:02 Will Barlow But let's talk about this verse 13, the unclean spirits. 1:24:07 Will Barlow What are these demons on your view? 1:24:09 Will Barlow Is this a mental illness that he has? 1:24:11 Will Barlow Is that your take on this? 1:24:13 Jon Burke I would regard this as a man afflicted by a mental illness. 1:24:19 Jon Burke And I would describe this as a phenomenological description for the benefit of the uncatechized or the pre-catechized. 1:24:26 Jon Burke Again, coming back to John, none of this is in John. 1:24:31 Will Barlow So you don't think that the pigs actually went into the water, right? 1:24:36 Jon Burke I believe they did. 1:24:37 Jon Burke I believe whatever kind of derangement was in the man ended the pigs. 1:24:42 Jon Burke And I mean, this has again been discussed in scholar literature that it was possible there was some disease in the man. 1:24:50 Jon Burke And this is simply a pre-scientific reference to a zoonotic illness crossing over from animals to humans and back again. 1:25:00 Jon Burke I don't think this is a necessity to go that far because that's actually sometimes brought in by textual critics or higher criticism as an argument against the supernatural origin of the Bible. 1:25:14 Jon Burke But it's recognized that it could well be describing something like that. 1:25:18 Will Barlow Sean, if I could have time for one more question real quick. 1:25:22 Jon Burke I'm happy for. 1:25:23 Jon Burke Go ahead. 1:25:24 Sean Finnegan One more. 1:25:25 Will Barlow What do you make of the fact that the narrator describes him as having an unclean spirit? 1:25:29 Will Barlow It's not just, like it's not just Jesus accommodating this man's belief that the narrator himself says that this man has an unclean spirit. 1:25:37 Will Barlow Verse 2. 1:25:38 Jon Burke I think it's more important that the narrator describes it as an unclean spirit because that means it's the narrator's phenomenological description of what's happening. 1:25:46 Jon Burke I think it's more significant that Jesus doesn't 1:25:48 Jon Burke diagnosed the man as having an unclean spirit or demonic position, just like he never diagnoses anyone as having an unclean spirit or demonic position. 1:25:57 Jon Burke And I think that's really significant because if Jesus knew that people were demonically possessed, if he could identify when somebody was suffering from an evil spirit, then he's the person who should have been first in line to say so. 1:26:11 Jon Burke But he never does it, Paul never does it, James never does it, I don't see any of the apostles ever doing it. 1:26:18 Sean Finnegan All right. 1:26:19 Sean Finnegan Well, we're going to reverse it and John, you'll be asking the questions for 15 minutes and Will will be in the hot seat. 1:26:27 Sean Finnegan Are you ready to get started? 1:26:29 Jon Burke Yep, sure. 1:26:30 Sean Finnegan All right. 1:26:33 Jon Burke Will, leaving aside the Bible for the moment, which would you say are the Second Temple period or even earlier extra biblical sources which are an accurate representation of your view of Satan and demons? 1:26:46 Jon Burke This is not a gotcha or anything. 1:26:48 Jon Burke It's the kind of question I actually should have asked before we had this debate. 1:26:52 Jon Burke This is just simply for my personal interest, so I can get more of a background of your understanding. 1:26:57 Will Barlow Yeah, honestly, I wanted to read Enoch before we had this debate. 1:27:01 Will Barlow I just ran out of time. 1:27:02 Will Barlow I was focusing more on Duncan Heaster's book and your prior debates and things like that. 1:27:07 Will Barlow lots of things I'd love to dig into in the future, but I would have to say I don't know too much other than what you shared in your presentation and with Anthony and then today. 1:27:17 Will Barlow I don't know too much about the intertestamental period. 1:27:20 Will Barlow Although, as I pointed out, I think in my rebuttal, I think it is striking to me that at the same time when monotheism was increasing and increasing post-exile, that this is also when the idea of the devil and demons came into this second temple period. 1:27:36 Will Barlow period and really became being thrown around. 1:27:39 Will Barlow And again, maybe it's Persian influence, but however we handle that, it's not inconsistent with strict monotheism because the strictest they were monotheists was the most they believe in devil and demons. 1:27:50 Will Barlow I'd say the other thing I'd say about that topic generally is that basically I would say that every ancient culture, as far as I understand it, believed in demons or in multiple gods. 1:28:01 Will Barlow and worship multiple gods. 1:28:03 Will Barlow And I would say from a phenomenological perspective, I would argue, and we can talk about specific texts if you'd like to, like for example, the prophets of Baal with Elijah. 1:28:13 Will Barlow From A phenomenological, psychological perspective, I would argue that that's actually really good evidence that these beings exist. 1:28:21 Will Barlow Because we would expect that if that's what everyone believed. 1:28:26 Will Barlow And like I said in my rebuttal with Deuteronomy, God gave them over, all the other nations of the world over to worship these other gods. 1:28:35 Jon Burke Okay, thanks for that. 1:28:36 Jon Burke And again, I don't have a follow-up question about the Second Temple sources. 1:28:40 Jon Burke That was Nagotcha, that's just my own understanding. 1:28:43 Jon Burke But since you've raised this question, this was a question I'd like to ask. 1:28:47 Jon Burke Do you believe that the Old Testament 1:28:49 Jon Burke teaches that Yahweh is not the only God, that the gods of the heathen do exist, they're competing gods, and we have the choice to worship them or not just as the ancient Israelites did, but that Yahweh will punish us if we do. 1:29:06 Jon Burke And again, not a gotcha, just asking for your view. 1:29:08 Will Barlow Yeah, for sure. 1:29:09 Will Barlow So Elohim, I think we both are going to agree that the word Elohim is used very flexibly in the Hebrew scriptures. 1:29:16 Will Barlow Moses is called Elohim. 1:29:17 Will Barlow There's lots of 1:29:18 Will Barlow beings called Elohim, like Psalm 82, however we understand it, whether that's angels or evil supernatural powers or humans, that's another Elohim reference. 1:29:28 Will Barlow So yeah, I mean, I think that there are other beings called Elohim. 1:29:33 Will Barlow Now, if the question you're asking me is, do I think that this evidence suggests that like Baal really did exist, but as a demon or that Moloch really existed as a demon, 1:29:43 Will Barlow My answer to you is I think that's probably the right answer, that yes, these beings did really exist. 1:29:51 Will Barlow Now, was the worship of them always consistent with that? 1:29:54 Will Barlow No. 1:29:54 Will Barlow I mean, I think there's a lot of reference, for example, in the later prophets of worshiping the dead kings, the souls of the dead kings and bringing the bones of the kings out of their graves and doing stuff with that. 1:30:06 Will Barlow And so I would say that those things are not real Elohim. 1:30:10 Will Barlow Those aren't really gods. 1:30:12 Will Barlow But no, I think like Moloch and Baal, I do think that those are demonic forces. 1:30:16 Will Barlow There are demonic forces behind those entities and that people really did experience something supernatural at times. 1:30:22 Jon Burke Okay. 1:30:23 Jon Burke So just to be clear, you would believe that they are demons or some kind of evil spirits, but not gods in the same way that God is God? 1:30:33 Will Barlow Yeah, God is the only, Yahweh the Father is the only uncreated Ase 1:30:39 Will Barlow all-knowing, all-powerful, however you define all-knowing and all-powerful, everywhere present, you know, those types of characteristics. 1:30:46 Will Barlow I think, you know, we're both biblical Unitarians. 1:30:49 Will Barlow Jesus gets obviously conferred some of those powers in maybe a limited way or a subordinate way. 1:30:58 Will Barlow Right, sure. 1:30:59 Will Barlow At times. 1:31:01 Will Barlow So certainly after the resurrection and ascension. 1:31:03 Will Barlow So yeah, that's how it is. 1:31:05 Jon Burke No, thanks. 1:31:06 Jon Burke I'd just like to clarify that because we both agree then that Yahweh is the only God and that means that the gods of the heathen aren't real gods, in which case then, yes, your fallback is that, well, they are some form of evil spirit. 1:31:20 Jon Burke My take is that the Old Testament doesn't treat them that way. 1:31:24 Jon Burke and Paul adopts the same view as the Old Testament, and so does Revelation. 1:31:29 Jon Burke That's my view. 1:31:31 Jon Burke Coming back to the question of outside the Bible, again, you started in the mid-2nd century early Christian literature, which is understandable, especially with Justin Martyr. 1:31:42 Jon Burke Which post-apostolic sources would you say are the most accurate representation of your view of Satan and demons? 1:31:48 Jon Burke Again, not a gotcha, just a kind of question I should have asked before the debate. 1:31:53 Will Barlow I mean, I think all of those, the ones I cited are all, I think, fairly close to my view. 1:31:59 Will Barlow I mean, I think Tertullian in particular, I mean, I come from a charismatic or Pentecostal background, which would be another great debate for another time. 1:32:07 Will Barlow So, he's talking about people casting out spirits before people walk into church services, you know, so I'm all for that, brother, if that's needed, you know, so yeah. 1:32:20 Jon Burke Okay, thanks. 1:32:20 Jon Burke Again, that was just for my reference to help my understanding. 1:32:24 Jon Burke Okay, so again, as a short one-off question, do you believe your understanding of Satan and demons is taught in the Old Testament? 1:32:35 Will Barlow I don't think it's taught, no. 1:32:37 Will Barlow I think, again, giving my opening statement, I think that Job is interesting because there's lots of, I know there's lots of off-ramps for you and I concede that. 1:32:48 Will Barlow And I think Zechariah, the reason why I didn't even bring up Zechariah is it's the same sort of story in Zechariah, right? 1:32:54 Will Barlow Genesis, the problem I think you have with Genesis 3, and then I think you have even probably, well, it depends on how you view it. 1:33:01 Will Barlow The problem in Genesis 3 is that it gets referenced so many times, different creatures. 1:33:06 Will Barlow And I know, I think your view on this is it starts off as a serpent, it ends up as a dragon or a really big beast in the book of Revelation. 1:33:14 Will Barlow And it's like, if we don't deal with our evil inclination, then it 1:33:17 Will Barlow grows over time and it gets worse and worse. 1:33:19 Will Barlow And I think that's an interesting take. 1:33:21 Will Barlow I don't ultimately find that compelling. 1:33:25 Will Barlow But I do think that serpent, large creature imagery gets used. 1:33:32 Will Barlow The Bible Project has a bunch of videos on that. 1:33:35 Will Barlow And I think that's sort of more my view on those things. 1:33:37 Will Barlow So I think Genesis 3 is more of a typological problem for you. 1:33:42 Will Barlow And then I say Daniel 10, which you didn't address in rebuttal. 1:33:46 Will Barlow Daniel 10 is perhaps the clearest window into what I think is actually going on. 1:33:51 Will Barlow And I just want to clarify something here, because Daniel 10 reminds me of something that I actually think that the Christadelphian view of sin, like I've said before in this debate, your view of sin is not a problem to me. 1:34:02 Will Barlow I don't have a problem thinking that 80% 1:34:05 Will Barlow or 90% of the sin that we experience comes from inside of us. 1:34:09 Will Barlow Now I would say that's influenced by external environmental factors as well, but I think the evil inclination or the 1:34:15 Will Barlow this internal propensity to sin is one problem. 1:34:18 Will Barlow And I agree with you. 1:34:19 Will Barlow That's why the Bible treats it one way. 1:34:21 Will Barlow I think this cosmic battle piece of it that's Daniel 10 is so alive and living for me is your greater problem. 1:34:28 Will Barlow And it's why Ephesians 6 is hard for you. 1:34:31 Will Barlow It's why these other texts are difficult. 1:34:33 Will Barlow And I think honestly that the demonology that we see in the gospels is actually trying to display that same cosmic battle 1:34:41 Will Barlow in those terms, in individual one-on-one encounter terms. 1:34:44 Will Barlow I think that's what Matthew, Mark, and Luke are doing explicitly. 1:34:48 Jon Burke Thanks for that. 1:34:49 Jon Burke That's helpful. 1:34:49 Jon Burke And again, it's great that we have very solid agreement on a number of these issues. 1:34:55 Jon Burke To my mind, when Daniel talks, the Book of Daniel talks about an angel being opposed by the Prince of Persia, well, I don't see any reason to 1:35:06 Jon Burke interpret Prince of Persia as evil demon when it says Prince of Persia. 1:35:11 Jon Burke And to my mind, if Jacob can wrestle with an angel until the break of day, such that the angel has to exercise explicit supernatural power to deal with this very human mortal, then I don't see why an angel who, of course, as we know, has limited power and compared to God 1:35:31 Jon Burke wouldn't have some difficulty in orchestrating events in opposition to what is described as a prince of Persia, which to me is just a mortal man or a mortal ruler. 1:35:44 Will Barlow If I can respond, if you have a. 1:35:46 Jon Burke Question on that, go ahead. 1:35:48 Will Barlow Yeah. 1:35:49 Will Barlow So I would say that the Jacob incident is interesting because I would say the angels 1:35:54 Will Barlow however we want to describe them. 1:35:55 Will Barlow I sort of like, I'm a science guy, so I would sort of like to describe them as like maybe having access to like a fourth spatial dimension. 1:36:03 Will Barlow They can sort of pop in and out of view whenever they want to. 1:36:05 Will Barlow They can sort of appear to be wherever they want to be and then disappear when they want to disappear. 1:36:10 Will Barlow And so I think the angel was limiting his power when he was wrestling Jacob. 1:36:14 Will Barlow I think that's the natural interpretation of that. 1:36:17 Will Barlow When you say that an angel appears to Daniel, presumably in his prayer closet, 1:36:22 Will Barlow I don't think the Bible describes him in a way where he's like walking up the steps and he has to physically make this journey. 1:36:27 Will Barlow I think he's popping into existence right next to Daniel. 1:36:30 Will Barlow And I think on that reading, understanding it that way, your view on that, I think, is almost impossible. 1:36:37 Will Barlow Because what could keep a fourth dimensional being from making it to Daniel's bedside or prayer room? 1:36:45 Will Barlow I don't think any human could do that. 1:36:48 Jon Burke I don't read the text as saying, I was trying to use my power to come to you, but this Prince of Persia prevented me using my power. 1:37:00 Jon Burke I believe he was saying I was delayed because I was dealing with this human adversary of God. 1:37:06 Jon Burke I was doing God's business. 1:37:07 Jon Burke I had to sort out this business with God, of this opponent of God, who just like, for example, 1:37:14 Jon Burke the angel's next work for God was delayed by the hours that he spent wrestling with Jacob. 1:37:24 Jon Burke But moving to my next question, how do you, given we both agree that the forensic view of temptation and sin and the evil inclination is 1:37:37 Jon Burke a cause of temptation and sin. 1:37:38 Jon Burke How would you differentiate between temptation from Satan and temptation from what we could call for the sake of the argument, the evil inclination or an internal temptation or just another person? 1:37:49 Jon Burke How would you differentiate? 1:37:50 Will Barlow Yeah, that's a great question. 1:37:52 Will Barlow And I give an example of this in my book, Explore What We Believe. 1:37:56 Will Barlow And so this is why I would say, one of my favorite, and this sounds bad, I'm smiling while saying this too, because I'm trying to be kind to you and polite to our guests online, but it's terrible, terrible. 1:38:06 Will Barlow subject, but Nazis is probably my greatest example of this. 1:38:10 Will Barlow So I would take, for example, that like Adolf Hitler and the people closest to him were possessed by demons. 1:38:18 Will Barlow I mean, that's my understanding of that historical event. 1:38:21 Will Barlow But the average private in the bunkers fighting against the Allied powers during that war, they were not demonized. 1:38:28 Will Barlow I don't think they were demonized. 1:38:30 Will Barlow But were they committing sin by fighting for a power that was doing such terrible damage to the world, to the Jewish people specifically, to all sorts of people, the ethnic cleansing and the different things that they were doing? 1:38:42 Will Barlow Yes, they were sinning. 1:38:43 Will Barlow And so their sin was not necessarily even explainable by an evil inclination. 1:38:48 Will Barlow Their sin was explainable by the orders that they received. 1:38:51 Will Barlow Now, I think you would probably argue that would be 1:38:57 Will Barlow that would be maybe Adolf Hitler's evil inclination or something like that. 1:39:01 Will Barlow I think Hitler is so, messed up and so terrible that I'd like to believe that he was, you know, taught to do evil by supernatural evil beings. 1:39:10 Jon Burke But so you say it's like the scale or severity of the sin is a differentiating factor. 1:39:18 Will Barlow I think you would not have got to just to clarify. 1:39:22 Will Barlow So let's take a more garden variety sin. 1:39:25 Will Barlow Let's take lust, for example. 1:39:27 Will Barlow I think that you could have a predisposition towards lust that's just part of your evil inclination. 1:39:33 Will Barlow I also think that after **** use or after premarital sex or after certain sinful activities, that perhaps there is a demonic element where you become attached to that thing. 1:39:43 Will Barlow You become attached to *********** you become attached to your lust in a way that you didn't have just through your evil inclination. 1:39:49 Will Barlow So that's another example that I would give to sort of clarify the difference between the two. 1:39:53 Will Barlow I do think that the beginnings of the problem probably are mostly just internal inclination plus maybe an external factor of some sort. 1:40:02 Will Barlow But then over time with repetitive use, I think it might become demonic. 1:40:06 Jon Burke Okay, thanks for that. 1:40:08 Jon Burke I appreciate you clarifying. 1:40:10 Jon Burke To my mind, if I personally 1:40:12 Jon Burke can't tell the difference between a supernatural evil being is tempting me or I am being tempted by a human or myself, then the doctrine has little utility. 1:40:26 Jon Burke And that's just a simple statement. 1:40:29 Jon Burke I'm not going to ask you another question. 1:40:31 Jon Burke Can I just clarify my view on that? 1:40:33 Will Barlow Yeah, just to say something briefly, one of the cases I think that's very interesting recently was Lindsay Clancy here in the United States and 1:40:40 Will Barlow she murdered her small children and a very tragic event. 1:40:44 Will Barlow And one of the things that she said in the trial was that she felt like she had an out of body experience while it was all going on. 1:40:50 Will Barlow And for me, that's another signal perhaps of demonic possession. 1:40:53 Will Barlow And again, I don't want to believe that anyone has the ability innately as a human being to be that evil, to murder their own small children in that kind of a fashion. 1:41:04 Will Barlow And so that would be another indicator for me. 1:41:06 Will Barlow So I think that there are, I think, psychological anecdotal things that would lead me to believe in the demonic. 1:41:13 Jon Burke Thanks. 1:41:14 Jon Burke I know in our pre-debate discussion, you acknowledge that, sure, we can't just say every illness is a product of demonic possession, especially when it comes to mental illnesses, very clear and potentially harmful to simply blanket everything with that explanation. 1:41:31 Jon Burke So how would you diagnose demonic possession and how would you exorcise someone? 1:41:38 Will Barlow Yeah, well, the power of the Spirit, that's the simple answer. 1:41:40 Will Barlow And as a sort of more grammatical answer for you, there's many times in the Bible where it says he healed all those who had diseases and he cast out all their demons. 1:41:50 Will Barlow And the word and Kai is there present in between those two things. 1:41:54 Will Barlow And it's the same kind of thing that I notice when I debate a Trinitarian and I say, look, every time Paul's epistles begin with God our Father and the Lord Jesus Christ. 1:42:02 Will Barlow See, there's a big little word here called and. 1:42:05 Will Barlow so I think Jesus does differentiate between them. 1:42:07 Will Barlow And I think therefore we should as well. 1:42:09 Will Barlow And I think that the Spirit of God is what would tell us which one is going on. 1:42:13 Sean Finnegan Thank you, gentlemen. 1:42:14 Jon Burke Thanks very much. 1:42:14 Jon Burke Appreciate it. 1:42:15 Sean Finnegan At this time, we are going to do our closing statements. 1:42:19 Sean Finnegan Let me just pop that up, making our way through. 1:42:23 Sean Finnegan this debate. 1:42:25 Sean Finnegan We've got a 10 minute block here, 5 minutes each for closing statements. 1:42:29 Sean Finnegan First up is going to be Will. 1:42:32 Sean Finnegan Are you all ready to go, Will? 1:42:34 Will Barlow Yes, let me. 1:42:37 Sean Finnegan A lot of rapid fire here, both of you, but. 1:42:39 Will Barlow Well, John's a pro and I'm catching up. 1:42:41 Will Barlow So here we go. 1:42:43 Will Barlow All right, I'm going to present my screen here. 1:42:44 Will Barlow Let me know if you see it. 1:42:46 Sean Finnegan Go ahead and pop that up. 1:42:48 Sean Finnegan Go ahead and start when you're ready. 1:42:50 Will Barlow Here at the end, I just want to say I'm thankful to my dialogue partner, Jonathan Burke, for his graciousness and civility. 1:42:58 Will Barlow It's been an enjoyable conversation for me and I hope that he feels the same way. 1:43:02 Will Barlow At the beginning of the debate, I offered up a few keys. 1:43:06 Will Barlow I talked about how the Bible describes Jesus as teaching about the kingdom of Satan and as interacting with demons. 1:43:12 Will Barlow about how Paul and the other apostles speak of this grand conflict between good and evil that includes supernatural agents on both sides, and about how there are exegetical concerns that can be found in basically every major passage of concern in the New Testament. 1:43:26 Will Barlow I also want to add here that John added arguments in rebuttal. 1:43:29 Will Barlow And so if the audience would like to ask me my perspective on some of the things that he had in rebuttal, I would certainly appreciate it. 1:43:35 Will Barlow But here are the five main points I want you to take away from this debate. 1:43:39 Will Barlow Number one, the Bible portrays an epic cosmic fight between good and evil, often using personal terms. 1:43:47 Will Barlow Because of this, Christadelphian attempts to explain away a personal devil and demons flatten out this conflict between good and evil. 1:43:54 Will Barlow In other words, if the attack is internal, then your thinking and evil impulses are to blame. 1:43:59 Will Barlow If the attack is external, then in many cases, God is the one who's ultimately responsible. 1:44:05 Will Barlow The Christadelphian view thus makes God responsible for evil in a way that my view, where God simply and only permits evil, does not. 1:44:14 Will Barlow We saw this conceited in cross-examination with the explanation for Satan and Job as either a jealous man, in which case all the supernatural things done to Job are directly caused by God, or a righteous angel, in which case all the supernatural things are ordered by God and directly done by the righteous angel. 1:44:34 Will Barlow As we saw in rebuttal, the argument that strict monotheism supposes no supernatural evil personal power is crushed by the historical fact that the Jews were most monotheistic during the period that demons made their way into Jewish philosophy after the exile. 1:44:48 Will Barlow There simply is no conflict between belief in demons and monotheism. 1:44:53 Will Barlow The second thing I want to say is the Christelphian view really suffers exegetically in the New Testament. 1:44:58 Will Barlow As I pointed out in the rebuttal, there's no need for hand-wringing about the lack of evidence in the Old Testament. 1:45:03 Will Barlow There are plenty of other important doctrines that would fail that test as well. 1:45:07 Will Barlow There's also no need for hand-wringing over the fact that I don't have all the details about how all this works. 1:45:12 Will Barlow We don't have all the details on lots of other doctrines as well. 1:45:16 Will Barlow Notwithstanding that, the prophetic window that we get in Daniel 10 provides us with enough of a run-up into the New Testament, even if we discard the evidence in other places like Job and Genesis 3. 1:45:28 Will Barlow In looking at the gospels, the God-inspired writers assume the existence of devil and demons. 1:45:34 Will Barlow Jesus teaches about the devil and demons. 1:45:36 Will Barlow There is never a later clarification that Christianity has grown beyond that belief. 1:45:41 Will Barlow But the bottom line is this. 1:45:43 Will Barlow If Jesus believes something, we should too, if we claim to follow him. 1:45:48 Will Barlow The accommodation argument that Christadelphians make fails for many reasons. 1:45:52 Will Barlow Jesus didn't merely use familiar terminology. 1:45:55 Will Barlow He taught about Satan and extended explanations. 1:45:58 Will Barlow His actions and exorcisms go beyond simply accommodating someone's vocabulary. 1:46:02 Will Barlow His private teachings to His disciples reinforces rather than corrects the personal understanding of Satan. 1:46:08 Will Barlow The New Testament continues to teach about Satan and demons after Jesus' resurrection. 1:46:13 Will Barlow And so the accommodation theory needs an independent reason to identify these particular teachings as accommodation rather than simply assuming its conclusion. 1:46:22 Will Barlow You can't claim also that the synoptics are meant as an early catechism for new converts and that it accommodates bad theology. 1:46:29 Will Barlow Only one of those things can be true, and I pointed that out in Cross X. 1:46:34 Will Barlow And so I find that the evidence for an accommodation argument in this case is entirely lacking. 1:46:39 Will Barlow The final thing, or the fourth thing I want to say is the Christelphian view cannot make good sense of early church history, where church fathers are describing exorcisms just as the gospels do. 1:46:49 Will Barlow There is in fact no evidence of a Christian view like the Christadelphian view until much later in history. 1:46:55 Will Barlow And as I pointed out, even early Jewish writings talking about the yetzer hurrah or evil inclination often talked about such things alongside a belief in a personal devil. 1:47:04 Will Barlow The ancient Jews often did not think that these ideas are mutually exclusive and neither do I. 1:47:10 Will Barlow want to add that John brought up the Didache 1:47:12 Will Barlow And the Didache is a very short document and so it's not exhaustive. 1:47:15 Will Barlow That would be my answer there. 1:47:17 Will Barlow Number 5, the Christadelphian view leads to a strong view of the potential for evil within humanity. 1:47:23 Will Barlow I would like to think that some of the most terrible evils committed in human history were taught to humanity by very old, incredibly wicked agents of darkness. 1:47:32 Will Barlow The Christadelphian view is that any human being is capable of being Hitler, Pol Pot, or the Unabomber simply by lacking control over their inner evil impulses. 1:47:41 Will Barlow I find this to be a dark view of humanity. 1:47:44 Will Barlow In conclusion, this is my assessment of the Christadelphian case. 1:47:47 Will Barlow It can make sense of certain passages, but does not make exodical sense of the New Testament broadly. 1:47:53 Will Barlow Thank you very much. 1:47:56 Sean Finnegan All right. 1:47:57 Sean Finnegan Thank you, Will. 1:47:58 Sean Finnegan We're going to go ahead and bring Jonathan back. 1:48:02 Sean Finnegan And John, you've got 5 minutes for your closing statement. 1:48:06 Jon Burke Thank you, Sean. 1:48:08 Jon Burke I'd like to point out that I believe I have demonstrated, and this is very important to me, that there is a doctrinal unity on this subject between the Old and New Testaments. 1:48:17 Jon Burke They both agree on the definition of demons. 1:48:19 Jon Burke They both use terms like Satan and the devil in the same way. 1:48:23 Jon Burke And as I believe I have demonstrated, since there was already a personification of these terms in the Second Temple period, 1:48:32 Jon Burke It is beholden on the person who believes that this personification is not used in the New Testament to demonstrate why they think this is true. 1:48:43 Jon Burke I think it's particularly important that, as I have already demonstrated, we see in Matthew Jesus specifically identifying Peter as a Satan and, of course, 1:48:55 Jon Burke Peter describing Ananias' evil inclination as the Satan. 1:48:59 Jon Burke To my mind, these are two, among other, clear pieces of evidence that that personification of the evil inclination with the explicit term Satan was used and understood in the New Testament. 1:49:11 Jon Burke Now, likewise, I would appeal again to the hematology of Jesus and Paul. 1:49:17 Jon Burke Again, when we talk about systematic theology, 1:49:20 Jon Burke When it comes to specifically Jesus and Paul teaching about the entire process of temptation and sin, whether it's Jesus in the Gospels, Paul in Romans and Galatians, or James in his own letter, we find exactly the same process. 1:49:38 Jon Burke We find the forensic view of homatology, the human origin of evil and sin. 1:49:44 Jon Burke a natural human impulse, temptation by humans, and the remedy for sin is non-supernatural. 1:49:50 Jon Burke Again, it depends on the actions of the individual, their faith in God, help from other mortals, and their prayer to God. 1:49:59 Jon Burke And although, as Will said, the two views, the cosmological and the forensic, can operate 1:50:07 Jon Burke Together, we don't find when Jesus and Paul and James teach on the process of temptation and sin that they are to go together. 1:50:15 Jon Burke We don't read of either of them saying, well, sometimes it's this supernatural evil being or demons, and sometimes it's this other origin. 1:50:26 Jon Burke Whenever they speak explicitly on this topic, their teaching is consistent. 1:50:30 Jon Burke And it's consistent not only with Second Temple period literature precedence, but also with the Old Testament. 1:50:36 Jon Burke Coming back to Job, I think it's very clear that Job believed that God was responsible for his trials. 1:50:41 Jon Burke And at the end of the book of Job, when Job met God, God said, Yes, I was responsible. 1:50:48 Jon Burke It's very clear Job didn't know about any supernatural evil being. 1:50:52 Jon Burke And I think it's significant that the Satan in Job had to ask God to do things 1:50:59 Jon Burke and in fact or ask permission and God himself said that he was going to be doing that. 1:51:06 Jon Burke I believe I demonstrated a Christadelphian view in pre-Christian Jewish literature, not simply a view of the evil inclination, but an explicit rejection acknowledged by many scholars of supernatural evil beings. 1:51:23 Jon Burke pre-Christian Jewish literature explicitly rejecting supernatural evil beings, even while it still uses terms like Satan and the devil of the evil inclination and of human opponents. 1:51:36 Jon Burke I believe that's a significant precedent, and that means that there is good reason to use that understanding as a hermeneutical tool for the New Testament uses. 1:51:46 Jon Burke I also demonstrated in the Didache, late first century, not simply, short document as it is, the absence of supernatural evil in beings, but their explicit rejection since the Didache used a pre-Christian Jewish source which included references to supernatural evil. 1:52:04 Jon Burke But when the Didache used it, those Christians stripped out every single reference to supernatural evil. 1:52:09 Jon Burke Not even a reference to Satan. 1:52:11 Jon Burke Not even a reference to the devil, not even a reference to demons. 1:52:14 Jon Burke All of that was stripped out and that's obviously a deliberate exegetical and hermeneutical choice. 1:52:20 Jon Burke I believe it's significant that Will started his appeal to Christian writers who accept his view or represent, at least in some part his view, in the mid-second century and not in the pre-Christian Jewish era or in the first century Christian era with the didarche. 1:52:40 Jon Burke Finally, I would say that the New Testament again explains how foundational gospel doctrines were foreshadowed in the Old Testament, but never says this of Satan and demons. 1:52:51 Jon Burke I also believe that the fruit of the doctrine of supernatural evil and Satan and demons has not been good. 1:53:02 Jon Burke We have seen an end to the witch hunts, we've seen an end to people being 1:53:07 Jon Burke exercised or thrown into prisons for being demonically possessed, as our understanding has improved, we've recognised that those are not the answer to the human ills. 1:53:22 Jon Burke If there are people who are demonically possessed, then hospitals should recognise them and they should be treated as such. 1:53:30 Jon Burke I think the absence of exorcism as a tool for treating people and the inability 1:53:35 Jon Burke differentiate between temptation of uh from a supernatural evil cause and from the evil inclination is significant thank you Sean and thank you will for your graciousness in our discussion. 1:53:48 Sean Finnegan All right thank you gentlemen for that uh exchange and we now have a number of questions that the audience has supplied and 1:54:01 Sean Finnegan We are trundling right along in the last section of our debate here, last 20 minutes, and that's going to be this Q&A period. 1:54:12 Sean Finnegan First up, first question, well, let me just say this. 1:54:16 Sean Finnegan I got a lot more questions for John than Will. 1:54:18 Sean Finnegan So I'm going to keep it even, but I'm going to start with John instead just because 1:54:25 Sean Finnegan He got more questions anyhow. 1:54:27 Sean Finnegan So John, first up, what I think I'll do is I'll ask you a question. 1:54:31 Sean Finnegan You answer it in a brief way as you can. 1:54:34 Sean Finnegan I don't think we're going to time it. 1:54:36 Sean Finnegan Just try to be relatively brief. 1:54:38 Sean Finnegan And then I'll turn to Will for basically a brief response. 1:54:44 Sean Finnegan So long as you will always be shorter than the one that took the initial answer, I think that'll be fair. 1:54:52 Sean Finnegan And if it gets too hard to keep track of, I will just employ a timer. 1:54:57 Sean Finnegan But all right, first question up for John. 1:55:01 Sean Finnegan In Genesis 3, 14 and 15, why was the serpent cursed before the woman and the man if it is only an evil inclination? 1:55:11 Jon Burke I don't believe the serpent was an evil inclination. 1:55:13 Jon Burke Genesis says it was a beast of the field. 1:55:15 Jon Burke It doesn't say it was evil inclination and it doesn't say it was supernatural evil being. 1:55:20 Sean Finnegan Okay, Will. 1:55:22 Will Barlow Yeah, I mean, I don't have too much to add other than what I shared earlier, which is that the serpent motif gets picked up later in scripture. 1:55:28 Will Barlow And so I think it takes more than just Genesis 3 to get there. 1:55:32 Sean Finnegan All right, for Will, do you know of anyone who believes in and practices supernatural spiritual gifts and accepts that miracles are possible today, but does not believe in the demons and Satans as real? 1:55:48 Will Barlow I can't think of anyone off the top of my head that holds that. 1:55:52 Will Barlow No, I think if you're more charismatic and you tend to believe in the gifts, then you also would agree that demons are real. 1:56:01 Sean Finnegan John, same question to you. 1:56:04 Sean Finnegan Is that a configuration that you're familiar with where they do believe in the spiritual gifts, but not in the devil and demons in the literal sense? 1:56:12 Jon Burke I have encountered that in some radical reformation and restorationist groups, especially those who are more influenced by the charismatic and Pentecostal side. 1:56:25 Jon Burke And in fact, in some fringes of the Christadelphian community that I have also seen that held. 1:56:32 Sean Finnegan Okay. 1:56:33 Sean Finnegan So for John, if Satan simply represents human wickedness and 1:56:40 Sean Finnegan What does it mean that Satan entered Judas? 1:56:43 Sean Finnegan Was Judas not already capable of wickedness before Satan entered him? 1:56:47 Sean Finnegan Can you comment about Satan entering into Judas? 1:56:50 Jon Burke Sure. 1:56:52 Jon Burke In the Jewish literature of the Second Temple period and the later Rabbinic literature, we find the idea of the evil inclination existing in humans with the process of temptation and sin as the arrival of a visitor. 1:57:06 Jon Burke In fact, some rabbis went so far as to describe the parable of Nathan when Nathan describes a man who had a lamb and a visitor who came to him and that the lamb was sorry, who came to the king and that the king took the lamb and killed it as a metaphor for the arrival of sin. 1:57:28 Jon Burke So Jewish literature didn't see any contradiction between the idea that there is 1:57:32 Jon Burke inclination in you, which leads to something which then arrives and that causes your sin. 1:57:41 Jon Burke And I believe, as I demonstrated previously, both in Genesis 3 and in James, we see that same process. 1:57:48 Jon Burke There's an inclination in you already, which is a weakness. 1:57:51 Jon Burke But as James says, that that needs to conceive and bring forth the sin eventually. 1:57:57 Jon Burke Even James there is describing the idea of something which is something which is 1:58:02 Jon Burke wasn't there in the beginning, something emerges. 1:58:07 Sean Finnegan Okay, Will, over to you, Judas and Satan entering him. 1:58:10 Will Barlow Yeah, I just want to point out that this happens in John chapter 13. 1:58:13 Will Barlow And there is an allegation that John doesn't really talk about spirits or exorcisms or much like that, which there's some truth to that. 1:58:20 Will Barlow But I do want to point out that this language of Satan entering into Judas occurs in the Gospel of John. 1:58:26 Will Barlow And I think that possibly the Christophian explanation is correct here. 1:58:30 Will Barlow Possibly this is just some sort of evil inclination. 1:58:33 Will Barlow But I think the point of what's happening in the Gospel of John specifically is Jesus is fighting against the powers of darkness. 1:58:40 Will Barlow He's fighting against the religious leaders who are rejecting him. 1:58:43 Will Barlow And what's happening here is Judas is buying into a wrong view of the kingdom. 1:58:47 Will Barlow He's buying into a wrong view of what Jesus' ministry is supposed to be. 1:58:51 Will Barlow And I think we're supposed to understand this as evil forces are helping him do the thing that he should not do. 1:58:56 Will Barlow It's part of this cosmic layer to the gospel, John, that I think is overlooked. 1:59:01 Sean Finnegan All right, for Will, what difference does it make in your personal life, whether the devil is real or not? 1:59:09 Will Barlow Well, again, I think on a personal level, when it comes to sin, when it comes to normal everyday temptation, I don't think there is much of a difference other than perhaps 1:59:19 Will Barlow perhaps recognizing trends in the culture and identifying where they line up with scripture or don't. 1:59:24 Will Barlow But you could do that without a belief in the personal devil or demons. 1:59:28 Will Barlow I'm assuming that Christadelphians do that kind of stuff all the time. 1:59:31 Will Barlow But no, I think this cosmic view of scripture, this cosmic fight between good and evil is an important part. 1:59:38 Will Barlow I think that there are questions about God's sovereign 1:59:41 Will Barlow underneath the surface here and about whether God causes or how directly he's involved in what we would call evil. 1:59:48 Will Barlow And so I think there is a question here that Christelphians have to answer because of that. 1:59:52 Sean Finnegan All right, John, what would you say on this as far as what difference it makes? 1:59:58 Jon Burke As I mentioned previously, I think it does make a difference. 2:00:01 Jon Burke I think historically has made a huge difference. 2:00:03 Jon Burke I personally believe that the fruits of supernatural evil have caused enormous destruction. 2:00:10 Jon Burke The witch hunts are a classic example. 2:00:13 Jon Burke Up till about the 13th century, it was standard Christian doctrine that witches did not exist. 2:00:20 Jon Burke There was no such thing as a human who could wield evil supernatural power. 2:00:25 Jon Burke And church leaders spoke against it, and Christian kings made laws against the belief. 2:00:31 Jon Burke Believing in witches was 2:00:33 Jon Burke not only contrary to canonical law, but to secular law. 2:00:36 Jon Burke And it wasn't until much later that that was lifted in the identification of witches as people led away by Satan and empowered by Satan, led to, well, the horror of a couple of centuries of witch hunts. 2:00:49 Jon Burke And I don't think anybody wants to return to that. 2:00:51 Jon Burke Ironically, when people actually started speaking less of Satan as the origin of 2:00:59 Jon Burke temptation and sin, the witch hunts suddenly just started to disappear. 2:01:04 Jon Burke And even those church leaders who at the time who really did believe in supernatural evil said, well, when we tell people, when we go to a village which is full of witch hunts and we institute an edict of silence, meaning no one's allowed to talk about witches, then suddenly there are no witches. 2:01:20 Jon Burke One Spanish Inquisitor famously said there were neither witches nor witchcraft until people spoke of them. 2:01:27 Jon Burke And he noted that when people stopped speaking about them, all the supposed causes and effects of witchcraft suddenly disappeared. 2:01:34 Sean Finnegan All right, another question for John. 2:01:35 Sean Finnegan If Satan represents sinful human desires and Jesus never sinned, what specifically makes those desires Satan rather than ordinary human appetites? 2:01:47 Jon Burke I'm not sure I completely understand the question, but I 2:01:52 Jon Burke if this if it helps, I believe that the Satan here is simply a description of. 2:01:57 Sean Finnegan It's the idea is that Satan, this questioner is equating Satan or defining Satan as sinful desire. 2:02:07 Sean Finnegan And so. 2:02:08 Jon Burke Oh, rather than rather than natural desires. 2:02:09 Jon Burke Okay. 2:02:10 Jon Burke I think the answer is to be found in James. 2:02:13 Jon Burke There are natural desires like eating, which are not a problem, but when those lead to eating in a contravened context, in a context where it breaks the law of God, then it becomes a temptation to sin. 2:02:27 Jon Burke I believe Paul makes the same point and Jesus likewise. 2:02:30 Jon Burke There are natural desires like eating, but if you are tempted to eat something which is forbidden, as in the case of Eve, that's when it becomes a sin. 2:02:44 Sean Finnegan With respect to Jesus, did he experience these sinful desires? 2:02:49 Jon Burke I believe Jesus was genuinely tempted to sin, yes. 2:02:52 Jon Burke And that's why I think that the description of the wilderness temptation is a problem for people who believe in supernatural evil because I can't see any genuine way in which Jesus could be honestly tempted to worship 2:03:05 Jon Burke an evil supernatural being. 2:03:06 Jon Burke All right. 2:03:07 Sean Finnegan Will, would you like to comment? 2:03:09 Will Barlow Yeah, my reading of the wilderness temptation is that Jesus is being asked to shortcut God's plan for his life and that therefore it is a real temptation. 2:03:19 Will Barlow It is an external temptation. 2:03:20 Will Barlow It's not an internal one. 2:03:22 Will Barlow And interestingly enough, I'm aware of John's response that he gave to Sir Antony in their debate, I believe, or maybe it was in the follow-up. 2:03:30 Will Barlow about how it was all in Jesus' mind and it was the same temptation that I'm describing, but he could have called the angels to do his bidding. 2:03:40 Will Barlow But the problem with that is that the Christadelphian view generally is that angels don't sin. 2:03:44 Will Barlow And angels being involved in the work of Jesus subjugating human empires would be sinful for angels to do. 2:03:51 Will Barlow And so it's hard for me to believe that Jesus would actually think that was a feasible 2:03:54 Will Barlow option. 2:03:55 Will Barlow So I actually think there's a problem for John here in this passage as well, even though we didn't discuss it during the debate. 2:04:00 Sean Finnegan For Will, if humans are still wholly responsible for their sin, what functional role does the devil play in your view? 2:04:10 Will Barlow Well, I've described it a couple of different times. 2:04:12 Will Barlow For example, high sources of evil, the cosmic powers of darkness as Paul describes it in Ephesians 6. 2:04:19 Will Barlow I think that influences our behavior in terms of forming cultures that are anti-God and forming habit patterns that are anti-God that are become normalized in our societies and cultures through different ages around the world at different times. 2:04:34 Will Barlow So I think those functions are all played. 2:04:37 Will Barlow I think that's one simple response there. 2:04:38 Will Barlow I'm sure there are others. 2:04:40 Sean Finnegan Okay. 2:04:41 Sean Finnegan John, you want to come back on that at all? 2:04:44 Jon Burke I would just reiterate what I said. 2:04:46 Jon Burke I think that, of course, as we know, everyone would agree that the doctrine of evil supernatural, the doctrine of supernatural evil in the form of Satan and demons is an explanation. 2:05:01 Jon Burke And to my mind, it's a solution looking for a problem. 2:05:05 Jon Burke I believe that the explanation is already given clearly in scripture and in our own experience. 2:05:11 Jon Burke it's pretty clear what's going on. 2:05:14 Sean Finnegan Okay, for John, in Luke 4, 33 to 35, a man had the spirit of an unclean demon and recognized Jesus as the Holy One of God. 2:05:24 Sean Finnegan Does this indicate the personality of the demon? 2:05:27 Sean Finnegan I'm sure you're familiar with this incident in other gospels too. 2:05:33 Jon Burke I think that's a great example of exactly what I would not expect of a supernatural evil being. 2:05:39 Jon Burke As I said previously, whenever we find people who are supposedly possessed by an evil supernatural being, I think it's remarkable that they start preaching the gospel, acknowledging that Jesus is the Son of God, is the Messiah, and should be obeyed. 2:05:53 Jon Burke To my mind, that is completely contradictory to the idea that these people are possessed by an evil supernatural being, which is tempting to lead them astray. 2:06:02 Sean Finnegan All right, Will. 2:06:03 Will Barlow I'm not aware of any relevant passages where the demon tells people that Jesus should be obeyed. 2:06:08 Will Barlow They do acknowledge his identity. 2:06:10 Will Barlow In this specific one, they say he's the holy one of God. 2:06:14 Will Barlow I would say that not only are they showing supernatural insight into who Jesus is, which is a motif in the gospels on its own, they're also violating what's called the messianic secret because Jesus didn't want the truth to come out about who he was too early in his career. 2:06:28 Will Barlow And this was going to cause him 2:06:29 Will Barlow conflict with the religious leaders before his time. 2:06:32 Will Barlow And so I think that there is an evil element here, subversive evil element to these incidents. 2:06:40 Sean Finnegan For Will, in Hebrews 2.14, it says that Jesus destroyed the devil. 2:06:45 Sean Finnegan How is that, I guess, destroyed the works of the devil, I suppose. 2:06:50 Sean Finnegan I don't know if you want to pull that up, but how? 2:06:53 Jon Burke Is the devil and his works? 2:06:55 Jon Burke I think it's the devil in his works. 2:06:57 Jon Burke I'm just going off my memory there. 2:06:59 Will Barlow Yeah, the Greek word there is katergeo, and it means to render idle, unemployed, inactive, and operative. 2:07:06 Will Barlow And yeah, I mean, I think the point I made in First John 3 in my opening statement is that the Jesus event changes humanity forever, and he expelled 2:07:16 Will Barlow and sheds light onto this part of the world that had been previously unknown or not clearly understood, this idea of the devil and demons and this spiritual conflict that's going on. 2:07:28 Will Barlow And again, the gospels are replete with examples of the spiritual cosmic battle going on. 2:07:32 Will Barlow And so the idea that Hebrews 2 is saying that, yeah, Jesus' death caused the devil to be inactive and deprive him of force. 2:07:40 Will Barlow or influence or power. 2:07:41 Will Barlow It certainly did. 2:07:42 Will Barlow It showed us the way out. 2:07:43 Will Barlow It shows the way to overcome not only the devil, but the death, the power that he has. 2:07:48 Will Barlow And so I think that's totally fine. 2:07:50 Sean Finnegan The questioner wants to know how is it possible that the devil is alive if he's been destroyed? 2:07:56 Will Barlow Right, because the word doesn't mean dead. 2:07:58 Will Barlow It means to render idle, unemployed, inactive, and operative. 2:08:01 Will Barlow That's what the word literally means if you look it up in a lexicon. 2:08:03 Sean Finnegan Thanks for that clarification. 2:08:04 Sean Finnegan John, do you want to come back on that? 2:08:07 Jon Burke I would say that if the devil has been rendered powerless and inoperative and inactive, then subsequent to the crucifixion, he no longer has a role to play in temptation and sin. 2:08:21 Sean Finnegan Okay. 2:08:22 Sean Finnegan For John, many scholars such as Jacob Milgram believe Azazel in Leviticus 16 was a goat demon. 2:08:29 Sean Finnegan Any comments on this identification from your Christadelphian perspective and in light of scholarship? 2:08:36 Jon Burke Yep, sure. 2:08:38 Jon Burke I think it's clear that, as I said previously, we have to get back to what the Old Testament understood, particularly what the law of Moses understood as a demon, and that is, a demon was a false god of the pagans which did not exist. 2:08:54 Jon Burke So the Azazel here, even if it's referring to a pagan goat demon, is still referring to a non-existent being. 2:09:06 Jon Burke And I can't think of anything more demonstrative of the powerlessness of a pagan god than the idea that you could represent it with a real goat, which you then kill. 2:09:17 Sean Finnegan Well, actually the. 2:09:18 Sean Finnegan The goat that was sent to Azazel wasn't the dead one, but your point is still your point is still made. 2:09:24 Jon Burke Yeah, I know it wasn't. 2:09:25 Jon Burke Yeah, it wasn't that. 2:09:26 Jon Burke Yeah, the idea is that the is that it's a symbolic destruction. 2:09:30 Jon Burke It's A symbolic destruction. 2:09:31 Jon Burke The goat is sent to. 2:09:32 Jon Burke Yeah, there's I know there's too much scholarship to go into this. 2:09:35 Jon Burke Yeah, exactly. 2:09:36 Sean Finnegan Will, did you want to come back on that? 2:09:38 Will Barlow No, I'm fine to keep that as it is. 2:09:41 Sean Finnegan All right. 2:09:42 Sean Finnegan For Will, by holding to the traditional view, how do you handle the extreme position that the devil and demons are hiding behind every tree? 2:09:53 Sean Finnegan You kind of mentioned this before, but could you comment on that? 2:09:57 Sean Finnegan And also, I guess there's some people that claim they have the gift of exorcism. 2:10:01 Sean Finnegan And how do you handle all the kind of abuses of this? 2:10:07 Will Barlow Yeah, again, I would say this. 2:10:10 Will Barlow First of all, I've known people that have described being exorcised of demons. 2:10:14 Will Barlow I know one person who said that she used to shake during worship and she was told she had a Leviathan spirit and she had that cast out of her and she no longer shakes during the worship of God. 2:10:26 Will Barlow And so the fact that there are these things that happen to people, I've known people healed from ailments that also was attributed to a demon. 2:10:34 Will Barlow And so, we can go round and round about whether that was an illness or a mental thing or this or that. 2:10:41 Will Barlow But the case is that I do believe that people do have that gift today. 2:10:46 Will Barlow Not all gifts, not all charismata are listed in the Bible. 2:10:48 Will Barlow There are unlisted gifts. 2:10:50 Will Barlow And I think this certainly could be one of them. 2:10:52 Will Barlow Jesus certainly operated this gift and believed in teaching others to operate this gift as the gospels clearly described. 2:10:59 Will Barlow And so, yeah, I mean, I think we should be aware of the spiritual conflict, like Paul says in Ephesians 6. 2:11:04 Will Barlow But the point is in Ephesians 6 not to be worried about the demons being around every tree, but just to be aware that our conflict is not with flesh and blood, but it is with these principalities and powers. 2:11:14 Will Barlow We should be looking to the world and recognizing where things are going wrong and avoiding the things that are wrong. 2:11:19 Will Barlow But we don't need to worry about the demons around every corner. 2:11:22 Sean Finnegan Okay, John, you want to come back on that? 2:11:25 Jon Burke If we can appeal to anecdotal evidence of people using 2:11:30 Jon Burke powers to, or such as exorcism powers, to expel people who are really possessed by real demons or evil spirits, then I believe we have to find some way of dealing with the mountain of anecdotal evidence for non-Christian witch doctors or shamans or other forms of 2:11:54 Jon Burke People who believe that they are wielding supernatural powers completely independent of Christianity and the God in which we believe in order to heal people and cast out their understanding of evil spirits, demons or anything else. 2:12:08 Jon Burke I think that just raises more problems than it resolves. 2:12:15 Sean Finnegan Okay, for John, at what point does a morally neutral desire become a Satan? 2:12:22 Jon Burke I think that James describes it very well in 1 James 1, sorry, James 1:13-2:15. 2:12:33 Jon Burke He says that every person is tempted when they are dragged away by their desire. 2:12:38 Jon Burke That is, that that desire pulls them into the intention to commit sin. 2:12:44 Jon Burke And I think it's significant that he speaks about people being drawn away or dragged away. 2:12:48 Jon Burke Again, personifying this evil impulse as something outside you which is pulling you to somewhere else. 2:12:55 Jon Burke It's when that desire turns into the intention to sin that there's a problem. 2:13:02 Jon Burke James says each person is tempted when they are enticed or dragged away by their own evil desire. 2:13:08 Jon Burke And then after that, 2:13:10 Jon Burke when that desire has conceived, when it's given birth to this thought of intention to sin, that's when sin results. 2:13:20 Jon Burke And of course, because when that, it gives birth to that sin and sin, when it is fully grown, gives birth to death. 2:13:28 Sean Finnegan Will, you want to come back on that? 2:13:30 Will Barlow Yeah, just briefly, just to say that the evil inclination, like I said before, maybe in James 1, I'm happy to concede that, but it doesn't mean, it actually I think provides a bigger 2:13:40 Will Barlow problem for the Christadelphian view, especially later in James and James 2, he talks about the demons believing something and shuddering. 2:13:47 Will Barlow And so look, here's the bottom line. 2:13:50 Will Barlow If evil inclination was all that it was, then we'd find the Bible filled with more personifications of those things. 2:13:55 Will Barlow Instead, we find a lot of talk about demons that's inconsistent with that. 2:14:01 Sean Finnegan So my next question has to do, starting with Will, 2:14:06 Sean Finnegan with theodicy. 2:14:08 Sean Finnegan And the question is, in light of your belief in the devil and demons, how does that affect your defense of God's justice when it comes to bad things happening to good people? 2:14:20 Will Barlow Yeah, so let me first start by saying that I don't think that humans can judge God. 2:14:23 Will Barlow If God does something, I believe he has morally sufficient reasons for doing it. 2:14:28 Will Barlow However, I did express a concern throughout this 2:14:30 Will Barlow probably one of my primary, if not my most primary concern, beyond the exegetical concerns I express, is this concern for theodicy, for this view of God's sovereignty, for this view of how this makes God. 2:14:42 Will Barlow Look, if you go to Job chapter 1 and 2 and you see a foreign agent coming in to present among the angels to God, hey, I want to mess with this guy, Job, what do you think? 2:14:52 Will Barlow And God's like, okay, you can go ahead and do that. 2:14:54 Will Barlow God's allowing this agent to do that. 2:14:57 Will Barlow If you say that that's an obedient angel, 2:14:59 Will Barlow then you're saying that God is not just allowing it, he's doing it. 2:15:03 Will Barlow If you say that it's a jealous human, then everything is God. 2:15:08 Will Barlow And the fact that Job doesn't understand that it's not this other agent is a whole part of the mystery. 2:15:15 Will Barlow Job 1 and 2 happens before the rest of the book. 2:15:18 Will Barlow Job doesn't see this thing happening in the beginning. 2:15:21 Will Barlow He's not privy to the scene. 2:15:23 Will Barlow We're privy to this vision of the throne room that he's not privy to. 2:15:27 Will Barlow And so for me, it is a huge concern. 2:15:29 Will Barlow And I think it is something that Christelphians have to reckon with, this idea that I think more evil is at God's feet because of this. 2:15:36 Will Barlow And again, I'm not saying this in a way that I can judge God. 2:15:38 Will Barlow I'm just saying it's a concern with the view. 2:15:41 Sean Finnegan John, you want to comment back on that? 2:15:43 Jon Burke Sure. 2:15:44 Jon Burke I think it's significant that in Job, Job is never tempted to sin. 2:15:49 Jon Burke Instead, his faith is tried. 2:15:51 Jon Burke That's the explicit question. 2:15:52 Jon Burke Does Job serve you only because you reward him? 2:15:58 Jon Burke And Job's faith in God is tested. 2:16:01 Jon Burke And the Bible tells us explicitly in the Old and New Testament that yes, God does test people's faith and He does intervene and give them trials specifically to do it. 2:16:09 Jon Burke But he does not try us more than we are able. 2:16:12 Jon Burke I think it's a bigger problem if a supernatural evil being comes to God and says, I would like to torment Job because I don't believe he's truly faithful. 2:16:21 Jon Burke And God says, fine, I give you permission to torment Job and visit on him all kinds of suffering. 2:16:26 Jon Burke Again, as far as Job's concerned, God is the person who caused his suffering. 2:16:30 Jon Burke And when they have a conversation later, 2:16:32 Jon Burke God confirms that. 2:16:34 Jon Burke But the reason was to test his faith. 2:16:37 Sean Finnegan For John, in 1 Corinthians, I think it's 15, Paul says Jesus will put all of his enemies under his feet. 2:16:46 Sean Finnegan Actually, correcting the questioner here, I think it was God will put all enemies under Jesus' feet, minor point. 2:16:53 Sean Finnegan But the question is, who are Jesus' enemies? 2:16:55 Sean Finnegan Who are the enemies mentioned? 2:16:58 Jon Burke All of the people who refuse to obey him. 2:17:02 Sean Finnegan Okay. 2:17:03 Sean Finnegan Will, you want to come back on that at all? 2:17:05 Will Barlow Yeah, the words used are rule and authority and power, and I'm assuming I am not going to, let's see. 2:17:15 Will Barlow Exusia, Dunamis, and Arche. 2:17:17 Will Barlow Yeah, those are some of the words that are found in Ephesians 6. 2:17:20 Will Barlow Look, I think that the whole point of Ephesians 1, Jesus being exalted above all the powers, the thing that Paul's saying there is he's exalted above not just Caesar, but the demons behind the power of Rome. 2:17:31 Will Barlow So I think that's the cosmic scale of evil is what's being talked about in 1 Corinthians 15. 2:17:35 Will Barlow I agree with the questioner here. 2:17:37 Sean Finnegan Okay. 2:17:40 Sean Finnegan Very good. 2:17:42 Sean Finnegan Question. 2:17:44 Sean Finnegan Who am I on? 2:17:44 Sean Finnegan Am I on Will? 2:17:46 Sean Finnegan Let's ask this. 2:17:48 Sean Finnegan What's that? 2:17:49 Will Barlow I said you're on me. 2:17:53 Sean Finnegan The question is to just ask you guys to each define the devil and demons. 2:17:59 Sean Finnegan So, you know, it can really go either way, but just in a brief way, give us a simple definition 2:18:06 Sean Finnegan of what the devil is, what demons are. 2:18:08 Sean Finnegan Will first and then John. 2:18:10 Will Barlow Yeah, the devil is a supernatural agent of evil and the demons are other supernatural agents of evil, presumably working on the devil's initiative. 2:18:19 Sean Finnegan Okay, John. 2:18:21 Jon Burke Satan and demon, Satan and the devil are words which refer either, or Satan in particular refers either to the evil inclination 2:18:29 Jon Burke in humans or a human adversary of God or one of God's servants, an adversary of one of God's servants or a servant of God, either human or angelic. 2:18:43 Jon Burke And demons are the false gods of the heathen which don't exist. 2:18:47 Sean Finnegan Okay, thank you guys. 2:18:49 Sean Finnegan That's going to conclude our Q&A session and also our entire debate. 2:18:55 Sean Finnegan Really appreciate your effort in having this conversation. 2:18:59 Sean Finnegan We've been going for over 2 hours. 2:19:01 Sean Finnegan It's a marathon, but you've held it together well. 2:19:05 Sean Finnegan Thanks also to you, John, for finding a good time, even though you're in a totally different time zone than we are. 2:19:15 Sean Finnegan So I'm glad that worked out. 2:19:19 Sean Finnegan Anything else you guys would like to say? 2:19:21 Will Barlow Thanks so much, John, for agreeing to do this. 2:19:23 Will Barlow It was a pleasure discussing this with you. 2:19:26 Jon Burke Yeah, I'd like to thank Sean for helping to arrange this. 2:19:28 Jon Burke And I'd particularly like to thank Will for the extraordinarily high tone of this discussion. 2:19:33 Jon Burke We had some very good and amicable discussion before this, which helped clarify issues. 2:19:38 Jon Burke We probably both didn't get enough 2:19:40 Jon Burke have an opportunity or didn't have enough time to answer some questions, which is why I asked a few simple questions, again, not as gods, but to help clarify my understanding. 2:19:50 Jon Burke And if, as I think it's possible, we may engage on this subject previously, I think it would be helpful that we've already had this discussion to clear some of the ground and maybe get to some of those other passages. 2:20:01 Jon Burke and maybe also flesh out our hermeneutical approach in more detail. 2:20:06 Jon Burke I know there are many questions a lot of people had in the chat, which we just didn't get to. 2:20:09 Jon Burke But thanks especially Will for your graciousness and the great tone of the discussion and Sean for keeping us to time. 2:20:19 Sean Finnegan Yeah, yeah. 2:20:20 Sean Finnegan So hey guys, appreciate your time. 2:20:23 Sean Finnegan If anybody would like to check out more about Resitudio, take a look at our website, resitudio.org. 2:20:29 Sean Finnegan I will have this debate posted there. 2:20:32 Sean Finnegan And if people want to go over there and make some comments, that will be available as well. 2:20:38 Sean Finnegan Thanks everybody and have a good night.